MileHacker Logo
Where to Stay in Door County

Where to Stay in Door County

Door County Wisconsin, USA Travel Guide

Accommodation Types

Traditional Stays

  • Hotels/Motels

    A range of options, from budget chains in Sturgeon Bay to upscale boutique hotels in northern villages. Standard services often come with these stays.

  • Bed & Breakfasts (B&Bs)

    Renowned for charm and intimacy. Unique decor, historical appeal, and gourmet breakfasts are common. Many focus on romantic getaways or quiet retreats.

  • Resorts

    Larger properties, often in popular villages like Fish Creek, Sister Bay, and Egg Harbor. They feature amenities like pools, on-site dining, and golf courses.

  • Vacation Rentals

    Private homes, cabins, or condos available through platforms like Airbnb and Vrbo. Good for groups and longer stays.

Unique Stays & Outdoor

  • Cottages/Cabins

    These generally have a rustic or cozy feel, from simple units to parts of larger resorts. Many are privately owned, offering a secluded "up north" experience.

  • Camping

    From primitive sites to full-service RV hookups in State Parks (Peninsula, Potawatomi, Newport, Whitefish Dunes) and private campgrounds.

  • Glamping

    Some properties offer pre-set luxury tents or yurts. This provides a comfortable camping experience without requiring your own gear.

  • House Sitting

    Consider options like TrustedHousesitters for unique stays and cultural exchange.

Neighborhood Guide

Door County’s villages and areas each possess a distinct character, offering different ambiances and proximity to attractions.

Southern & Central Hubs

Sturgeon Bay
  • Working waterfront with maritime history
  • Year-round businesses and services
  • Good central base, budget-friendly lodging
  • More "real town" feel
Sturgeon Bay Considerations
  • Less "quaint" or "resort-like"
  • Further from popular northern attractions

Northern & Lakeside Villages

Fish Creek, Egg Harbor, Sister Bay
  • Picturesque, bustling, many amenities
  • Direct access to Peninsula State Park (Fish Creek)
  • Lively nightlife & diverse dining (Sister Bay)
  • Beautiful bay views (Egg Harbor)
Northern Village Considerations
  • Can be very crowded and expensive during peak season
  • Parking challenges often occur
  • Noise levels often higher

Quiet & Rustic Retreats

Ephraim, Baileys Harbor, Ellison Bay/Gills Rock, Washington Island
  • Peaceful atmosphere, serene bay views (Ephraim)
  • Less crowded, natural charm (Baileys Harbor)
  • Rustic, authentic feel, Washington Island ferry gateway (Ellison Bay/Gills Rock)
  • Genuine escape, unique attractions (Washington Island)
Quiet Village Considerations
  • Limited dining and nightlife (Ephraim)
  • Fewer options compared to Green Bay side (Baileys Harbor)
  • Limited amenities, furthest from central attractions (Ellison Bay/Gills Rock)
  • Ferry travel required, limited amenities (Washington Island)

Safety & Proximity

Safety

All areas of Door County generally have a high level of safety. Serious crime is rare. Standard travel precautions are advisable.

Transportation

Proximity to attractions varies significantly. A car is necessary to explore the entire county comprehensively.

Booking Strategies

Plan your accommodation in advance, especially during popular seasons, to secure your preferred options.

When to Book

  • Peak Season (June-Aug, early Oct): Book 6-12 months in advance for desired dates.
  • Shoulder Season (May, Sep): Book 3-6 months in advance, especially for weekends.
  • Low Season (Nov-Apr): Last-minute deals are common. For events, book 1-2 months out.
  • Prices are highest in July, August, and early October. Lowest from November through April.

Where to Book & Policies

  • Online Travel Agencies: Booking.com, Agoda, Expedia, Hotels.com, TripAdvisor, IHG Hotels, Hostelworld.
  • Vacation Rentals: Airbnb, Vrbo, and local property management companies.
  • Direct Booking: Many B&Bs and independent resorts offer better rates on their own websites.
  • Policies: Deposit and cancellation policies vary. Always read them carefully before confirming.

Local Resources

Door County Visitor Bureau
  • The official website (Doorcounty.com) features a comprehensive list of lodging options.
  • It has direct links to booking pages or contact information for properties.
  • This resource helps you find a full range of properties.
Negotiation Customs
  • Negotiating walk-in rates is not common, especially during peak season.
  • Prices are generally fixed and non-negotiable.
  • Small discounts may occur in the quietest off-season for cash payments or extended stays.
  • This is not standard practice and should not be expected.

Important Booking Tip

State Parks

Book your camping site in Wisconsin State Parks well in advance, especially for Peninsula State Park. Sites fill quickly.

Popularity

Many popular properties book up 6-12 months in advance for specific dates, notably weekends and holidays during peak season.

Flexibility

For more flexibility, consider traveling during weekdays or outside the peak summer and fall foliage seasons.

Accommodation Recommendations

Door County has varied lodging experiences, allowing you to choose based on your budget, travel style, and preferences for amenities and location.

Traveler Specific Options

Family-Friendly Stays

Many resorts cater to families. Look for properties with playgrounds, pools, or easy access to beaches.

  • The Lodge at Leathem Smith (Sturgeon Bay)
  • Eagle Harbor Inn (Ephraim)
  • Vacation rentals (more space, kitchens)
  • Private campgrounds
Solo Traveler Choices

B&Bs provide a personal touch and welcoming atmosphere. Budget motels are practical. Camping connects with nature.

  • Charming Bed & Breakfasts
  • Budget Motels
  • State Park camping for solitude
  • Locations with easy access to trails

Extended Stays & Cultural Significance

Long-Stay Accommodations

Vacation rentals are ideal for a week or more, offering kitchen facilities and separate living areas.

  • Vacation rentals (full amenities)
  • Local property management companies
  • Some hotels (extended-stay rates off-season)
Cultural & Historical Significance

Many B&Bs are in historic homes. Some properties are famous for their unique charm or traditions.

  • The White Gull Inn (Fish Creek)
  • The Thorp House Inn & Cottages (Fish Creek)
  • Historic Bed & Breakfasts throughout the county

Typical Price Ranges Peak Season, per night

  • Luxury Hotel/Resort

    $400 - $1000+ (high-end amenities, pampering)

  • Mid-Range Hotel/Inn

    $150 - $400 (comfortable, convenient, amenities)

  • Bed & Breakfast

    $175 - $350 (personalized service, unique charm)

  • Vacation Rental (Home/Cabin)

    $200 - $800+ (space, privacy, kitchen for groups)

Budget & Outdoor Stays

  • Budget Motel

    $80 - $150 (most affordable, basic, practical)

  • Camping

    $20 - $40 (site fee) (close to nature, outdoor experience)

  • Best For Families

    Many resorts cater to families. Vacation rentals are often ideal, providing more room. Private campgrounds also have excellent facilities for children.

  • Best For Solo Travelers

    B&Bs or budget motels.

Price Fluctuation by Season

Peak Season Pricing

Accommodation prices are significantly higher in July, August, and early October (peak fall foliage).

  • Higher rates due to high demand.
  • Book far in advance.
  • Weekends and holidays are most expensive.
Low Season Savings

The lowest prices typically occur from November through April, with some slight increases around winter holidays.

  • Significant budget savings possible.
  • More flexibility with bookings.
  • Fewer properties are open.

Explore Diverse Accommodations

Bed & Breakfasts

For a personalized and charming stay, B&Bs are a signature Door County experience.

Vacation Rentals

Ideal for families or groups seeking more space and amenities like a full kitchen.

State Park Camping

Connect with nature and enjoy affordable lodging at one of the beautiful state parks.