MileHacker Logo
Where to Stay in Amish Country

Where to Stay in Amish Country

Amish Country Ohio, USA Travel Guide

Accommodation Types

Popular Choices

  • Hotels/Motels

    These range from budget-friendly chain motels to privately owned hotels. They provide standard amenities like private bathrooms and Wi-Fi.

  • Bed & Breakfasts (B&Bs)

    B&Bs are very popular for a bespoke experience. Many stand in charming, often historic, homes. They often serve home-cooked breakfasts.

  • Inns

    Larger than typical B&Bs, inns often have more amenities. These may include on-site restaurants, spas, or larger common areas. The Inn at Honey Run is an example.

  • Cabins/Cottages

    Available for rent, notably in rural or wooded areas. These provide more privacy, space, and a secluded feel. They often include kitchens.

Flexible Stays

  • Vacation Rentals

    Options like homes, apartments, or private rooms, catering to various group sizes and budgets. They allow flexibility, often with full kitchens.

  • Camping and RV Parks

    Several campgrounds stand in or near Amish Country. They offer sites for tents and RVs, ranging from basic facilities to those with full hookups.

  • Unique Local Accommodation

    Amish-owned or Amish-affiliated guesthouses a simpler, more authentic experience. These are often basic, with limited modern amenities, for a glimpse into a less commercialized lifestyle.

  • Direct Booking

    Many unique local places require direct booking and often operate on a cash-only basis.

Neighborhood Guide

Each a city in Areas Where the amish live brings its own unique character, providing different experiences for visitors.

Berlin, OH

Pros
  • Central location
  • Most amenities within walking distance
  • Easy access to many popular attractions
  • Very safe
Cons
  • Can be very crowded
  • Prices might be higher
  • May feel less quiet or "authentic"

Millersburg, OH

Pros
  • County seat of Holmes County
  • Larger town feel with the historic city center
  • Slightly quieter than Berlin
  • Good range of dining and historic architecture
Cons
  • Shops more scattered
  • Less focused on specific "Amish" tourism

Walnut Creek, OH

Pros
  • Scenic village
  • Known for family-style restaurants
  • Good for shopping unique handmade goods
Cons
  • Can get very busy at mealtimes
  • Limited nightlife

Sugarcreek & Rural Areas

Sugarcreek, OH

Known as "Little Switzerland" because of its Swiss heritage. It displays Alpine-style architecture and a large cuckoo clock. A good base for exploring the eastern side of Amish Country.

Rural Areas

Peaceful, scenic, with scattered farms and winding country roads. It creates a true immersion into the rural Amish lifestyle, offering seclusion and tranquility. Cell service may be spotty.

Booking Strategies

Booking Recommendations

  • Advance booking is highly advisable, especially for B&Bs and popular inns. This holds true for peak seasons (summer, fall foliage) and weekends.
  • Many popular places book months ahead, specifically unique B&Bs. For winter or off-peak weekdays, one might find more flexibility.
  • Negotiation is not customary for established hotels or B&Bs. Walk-in rates usually stand higher than those booked in advance.
  • Prices are highest during the summer and fall foliage season due to high demand. They drop during the winter months, not including holidays.

Policies and Platforms

  • Deposit and cancellation policies vary by property. Check these carefully before confirming your reservation. Most properties ask a deposit.
  • Properties often have a cancellation window (e.g., 24-72 hours prior to arrival) for a full refund. Understand these terms to avoid unexpected charges.
  • Directly booking through official websites of specific hotels, inns, or B&Bs often yields the best rates or deals. Many smaller B&Bs do not list on large platforms.
  • Booking.com and Expedia are choices for lodging and B&Bs, presenting a wide selection and user reviews.

Trusted Booking Platforms

Global & Specialty Sites
  • Booking.com (Global accommodation booking)
  • Agoda (Accommodation booking with Asian strength)
  • Hostelworld (Budget accommodation specialist)
  • Vrbo (Vacation rental booking site)
Hotel Chains & Unique Stays
  • IHG Hotels (International hotel group)
  • TrustedHousesitters (House/pet sitting exchange platform)
  • Airbnb (Vacation rentals)
  • Many smaller B&Bs do not list on large platforms, direct booking is often possible.

Important Note

Peak Season

Highly recommended to book several months in advance for summer, fall foliage, and weekends.

Pricing

Walk-in rates typically stand higher than pre-booked rates. Always book ahead.

Cancellation

Review cancellation policies to avoid unexpected fees. Policies vary by property.

Accommodation Recommendations

Examples and types of recommendations cater to different traveler needs. Always verify current reviews and availability.

Budget & Mid-Range Options

Budget Level

Motel/Basic Inn

  • Comfort Inn (Berlin)
  • Quality Inn (Millersburg)
  • Typical Price: $70 - $120 per night
Mid-Range Level

B&B/Mid-range Hotel

  • Berlin Grande Hotel (Berlin)
  • The Wallhouse Hotel (Walnut Creek)
  • Typical Price: $120 - $200 per night
  • Presents unique character, often includes breakfast, good service, local charm.

Luxury & Family-Friendly

Luxury Level

Upscale Inn/Resort

  • The Inn at Honey Run (Millersburg)
  • Typical Price: $200+ per night
  • High-end amenities, scenic views, often adults-only, fine dining on-site.
Family-Friendly Options

Hotels with Indoor Pools / Larger Cabins

  • Berlin Grande Hotel (indoor pool for kids)
  • Larger cabins or vacation rentals provide more space, separate bedrooms, and kitchens.
  • Stays On a farm on working farms offer an unique educational experience.

Solo & Long-Stay Options

  • Solo Traveler Recommendations

    Cozy B&Bs welcome solo travelers with a friendly, personal touch. Hosts often share conversation and local tips. Smaller hotels provide privacy and convenience.

  • Long-Stay Accommodations

    Vacation rentals have more space, amenities like full kitchens and laundry, making them suitable for prolonged visits. Some hotels include rooms with kitchenettes.

  • Extended Stay Discounts

    Inquire about weekly or monthly rates, as some places may provide discounts for longer durations.

Cultural & Historical Stays

  • Restored Historic Homes

    Numerous B&bs in Millersburg and other older small communities are beautifully restored heritage homes.

  • The Inn at Honey Run (Millersburg)

    Its architecture blends into the natural surroundings, creating a refined retreat. Its restaurant serves refined dining.

  • Amish-Affiliated Guesthouses

    For a simpler, very authentic experience, seek out private guesthouses from Amish families. These present cultural immersion and are found via local tourism offices.

Read Reviews

Check Online Reviews

Before booking, read recent reviews to gain knowledge into the property's cleanliness, service, and location from other travelers.

Traveler Insights

Reviews often share details about noise levels, amenities, and host interactions, helpful for deciding your stay.

Summary of Accommodation Types

Diverse Options

From standard hotels to unique Amish guesthouses, a wide array of options awaits.

Local Charm

Guesthouses and inns frequently stand in historic homes, creating a personal, charming experience.