MileHacker Logo
Best Restaurants in Indianapolis

Best Restaurants in Indianapolis

Indiana USA Travel Guide

Culinary Overview

Local Culinary Identity

Indianapolis'the food scene began with established Midwestern comfort food. It gained influence from German, Irish, and In the south U.S. Flavors due to historical immigration patterns.

A strong focus on farm-to-table dining, craft breweries, and innovative cuisine now define it.

Ingredients

  • Pork, especially pork tenderloin, features prominently.
  • Corn and seasonal vegetables are also staples.
  • Flavors tend to be hearty, savory, and sometimes sweet, as seen in the classic sugar cream pie.

Dining Customs & Practices

Meal Times:

Breakfast (7-10 AM), Lunch (12-2 PM), Dinner (6-9 PM)

Etiquette:

Casual dining is common. Fine dining establishments may require booking a table at a restaurant and have a dress code. Tipping is customary.

Regional Variations:

Indianapolis offers a wide variety of dining, from classic diners to upscale restaurants and a growing international food scene. Each neighborhood also contributes its unique flavor.

Must-Try Dishes

Signature Flavors

Pork Tenderloin Sandwich

Indiana’s unofficial state sandwich. A breaded and cooked in oil pork cutlet, often pounded thin. Served with pickles, onions, and mustard.

Find this at many small local restaurants and restaurants.

Sugar Cream Pie

Indiana’s official state pie. A rich, sweet, custard-like pie with a rich and smooth texture. Often topped with nutmeg.

A true Hoosier classic.

St. Elmo Shrimp Cocktail

A characteristic appetizer from the iconic St. Elmo Steak House. Jumbo shrimp served in a fiery, horseradish-laden cocktail sauce.

A legendary local heat experience.

Beyond the Classics

  • Hoosier Chili: Often served “three-way” with spaghetti and dairy product from milk. It resembles Cincinnati chili but carries its own regional twist.
  • Craft Beer: Indianapolis boasts a thriving craft beer scene. Numerous local breweries deliver a wide range of styles.

Culinary Reads

The Indianapolis Cookbook

Explore local specialties and even try making one at home with The Indianapolis Cookbook: Recipes, History, and Hoosier Lore.

Stay Hydrated

Stay hydrated with clean water while exploring the dining scene. A Brita Premium Filtering Water Bottle assists.

Dining Options

Fine Dining

Experience Indianapolis's upscale culinary scene.

  • St. Elmo Steak House
  • Harry & Izzy’s
  • The Capital Grille

Mid-Range & Boutique

Explore different flavors and unique atmospheres.

  • Bluebeard (Fountain Square)
  • Milktooth (Fountain Square)
  • The Eagle (Mass Ave)

Casual & Market Eats

Affordable and varied food choices.

  • Indianapolis City Market
  • Food Carts
  • Bottleworks District

Special Dietary Needs

Vegetarian & Vegan

MORE and more restaurants offer dedicated vegetarian and vegan menus.

Apps like HappyCow guide you.

Allergen Awareness

Many restaurants accommodate dietary restrictions.

Inform your server about any allergies when placing an order.

Global Flavors

Asian Cuisine

Concentrations on the west and south sides.

Hispanic Cuisine

Find robust flavors on the west and south sides.

Italian & European

Diverse options throughout downtown.

Other International

Explore various world cuisines.

Culinary Experiences

Engaging with Food

  • Cooking Classes and Food Tours: Various local culinary schools or specialized tour companies deliver cooking classes focusing on various cuisines. Walking food tours are popular in Fountain Square, Mass Ave, and the urban area center.
  • Connecting With farms And Food producers: Opportunities exist to visit local farms or food producers, especially during farmers' market seasons.
  • Food Festivals and Events: Devour Indy: A bi-annual restaurant week, held in winter and summer, has special prix fixe menus.
  • Unique Dining Concepts: Discover special dining concepts in revitalized areas, like the Bottleworks District, which offers varied food options in a historic setting.

Festival Highlights

Devour Indy

A bi-annual restaurant week, held in winter and summer, has special prix fixe menus.

A city-wide dining event.

Indy’s Original Oktoberfest

Celebrates German heritage with food, beer, and music.

An annual cultural gathering.

Market Discoveries

Market Options
Indianapolis The Main market in the city
Food Trucks
Farmers' Markets
Bottleworks District

A revitalized area featuring a food hall, restaurants, and entertainment.

  • Diverse food options
  • Historic setting
  • Lively atmosphere
Local Artisans

Opportunities to visit local food producers and find unique artisan goods.

Check local farmers' market schedules for definite spots and times.

Further Insights

Culinary History
  • Evolution of local cuisine
  • Impact of immigration
Regional Variations
  • Diners vs. Upscale
  • International concentrations

Additional Culinary Notes

Visitor Tips

Reservations

For fine dining, making reservations in advance is wise.

Especially on weekends | For famous spots
Informing Staff

Always inform your server about any allergies or specific dietary needs.

This helps restaurants accommodate you safely.
Tipping Guidance

Gratuity for service is customary in the U.S. For waitstaff, bartenders, and other service personnel.

Standard is 15-20% for good service.

Local Gems

  • Seek out local specials and seasonal menus at restaurants.
  • Explore small, independent bakeries and cafes for unique treats.
  • Discover craft cocktail bars and local distilleries for evening enjoyment.
  • Find unique offerings at local pizzerias, often with a Hoosier twist.

Seasonal Events

Look at local event schedules for pop-up dinners, food trucks rallies, or special tasting events.

These often present a food-related experience.

Local Community

Engage with local residents for authentic dining recommendations.

They often know the best hidden spots.

Spotlight: Local Brews

Sun King Brewery

A prominent local brewery, known for its diverse beer selection and taproom.

Metazoa Brewing Co.

A brewery supporting animal welfare, with pet-friendly spaces and unique brews.

Indianapolis Craft Scene

Investigate several microbreweries and distilleries throughout the city's neighborhoods.

Traveler's Culinary Advice

Embrace the local food scene by venturing beyond downtown into areas such as Fountain Square and Mass Ave for authentic flavors.

  • Sample the iconic Pork Tenderloin Sandwich and Sugar Cream Pie.
  • Explore the Indianapolis The Main market in the city for diverse local vendors.
  • Explore the thriving craft beer scene.
  • Always inform staff of dietary needs for a safe experience.
  • Participate in a food tour to sample multiple offerings.