MileHacker Logo
Best Restaurants in Hilton Head

Best Restaurants in Hilton Head

Hilton Head South Carolina, USA Travel Guide

Culinary Overview

Cultural and Historical Context of Local Cuisine

Hilton Head Island's cuisine has deep roots in Lowcountry Cuisine, a distinct culinary tradition of coastal South Carolina and Georgia. It shows the region's historical influences.

The cuisine emphasizes fresh, local ingredients from the sea and the land. It stands out with seafood, rice, and fresh vegetables.

Ingredients and Flavors

  • Seafood: Shrimp, oysters, crabs (especially blue crabs), and fish like grouper, snapper, and mahi-mahi.
  • Grains: Carolina Gold Rice, a historic regional staple, and grits.
  • Vegetables: Okra, collard greens, sweet potatoes, and corn.
  • Flavors: Often savory, sometimes spicy, with influences of smoky bacon or ham, butter, and seasonings like Old Bay. Sweet tea is everywhere.

Dining Customs and Etiquette

Reservations

Highly recommended for popular restaurants, especially during peak season and for dinner. Use apps like OpenTable or call directly.

Dress Code

Most restaurants are casual. Some upscale restaurants may suggest "resort casual" attire (no swimwear and collared shirts for men).

Tipping

Customary and expected. 15-20% for good service.

Meal Times and Structures

  • Breakfast: Typically 7:00 AM - 10:00 AM.
  • Lunch: Typically 11:30 AM - 2:00 PM.
  • Dinner: Typically 5:00 PM - 9:30 PM. Many restaurants present early bird specials or "happy hour" menus before 6:00 PM.
  • Regional Variations within Hilton Head: Different restaurants may highlight specific aspects of Lowcountry cuisine, from fine dining interpretations to casual, fresh seafood preparations. Some focus on Gullah influences.

Must-Try Dishes

Signature Dishes & Where to Find Them

Shrimp & Grits

Creamy grits, often cheese grits, topped with sautéed shrimp, bacon, and a savory gravy. A Lowcountry staple.

Find at: Old Oyster Factory, A Lowcountry Backyard.

She-Crab Soup

A rich, creamy soup made with crab meat, roe, and a touch of sherry.

Find at: Hudson's Seafood House on the Docks, Black Marlin Bayside Grill.

Lowcountry Boil Frogmore Stew

A communal dish with shrimp, sausage, corn on the cob, and potatoes boiled together with seasoning.

Find at: Many casual seafood restaurants, or as a catered event.

More Local Flavors

  • Oysters (local, especially May River oysters): Freshly shucked raw oysters, steamed oysters, or fried preparations.
  • Fried Green Tomatoes: Sliced green tomatoes, breaded and fried, often with a remoulade sauce.
  • Pimento Cheese: A popular spread made from cheddar cheese, pimentos, and mayonnaise. Often served as an appetizer or on sandwiches.
  • Deviled Crab: Crab meat mixed with seasonings, breadcrumbs, then baked in a crab shell.

Snacks and Beverages

Iconic Snacks & Desserts

Pecan Pie, Peach Cobbler (seasonal), Lime Pie.

Traditional Beverages

Sweet Tea (ubiquitous), local craft beer (Hilton Head Brewing Company), bourbon, and rye whiskey.

Dining Options

Fine Dining Establishments

For an upscale culinary experience.

  • The Jazz Corner: Live jazz with upscale American cuisine.
  • Ciao Amici: Italian fine dining.
  • Charlie's L'Etoile Verte: French-inspired seafood. Red Fish: Contemporary American with fresh seafood.

Mid-Range Restaurants

Comfortable dining with various choices.

  • Skull Creek Boathouse: Waterfront seafood with a lively atmosphere.
  • Hudson's Seafood House on the Docks: Historic, casual, fresh seafood.
  • A Lowcountry Backyard Restaurant: Authentic comfort food in a relaxed setting.

Budget Eateries & Markets

Affordable choices for quick meals and fresh ingredients.

  • Stack's Pancakes & More: Popular for breakfast and brunch.
  • Local Pie: Casual pizza. Waffle House: Classic American diner.
  • Farmers Markets (Coastal Discovery Museum, Bluffton) and Seafood Markets.

International Cuisine Options

Variety of Cuisines

Italian, Mexican, Chinese, Japanese (sushi), Thai, and some Indian restaurants are on the island.

Explore diverse flavors.

Specific Choices

For specific international dishes, check local listings or online reviews for the latest options.

New establishments may appear.

Special Dietary Considerations

Vegetarian & Vegan

Most restaurants accommodate requests, though dedicated vegan spots are limited.

Halal & Kosher

Dedicated options are limited. Larger grocery stores may stock Kosher items.

Gluten-Free & Allergens

Many restaurants are aware. Communicate clearly. Cross-contamination is a risk.

Resources

Use review apps or call restaurants in advance. Self-catering in vacation rentals is most flexible.

Culinary Experiences

Engaging with Food Culture

  • Cooking Classes: Some resorts or culinary centers may offer classes focused on Lowcountry cuisine.
  • Food Tours: Limited dedicated food tours on Hilton Head. The Bluffton Food Tour in nearby Bluffton has a walking tour with food tastings.
  • Gullah Culinary Experiences: Some Gullah heritage tours include a meal or cooking demonstration.
  • Farm Visits & Food Producers: Farmers Markets offer chances to meet local farmers. Seafood Markets present fresh, locally caught seafood.

Unique Dining Concepts

Waterfront Dining

Many restaurants present views of the Intracoastal Waterway, marshes, or the ocean. Skull Creek Boathouse, Hudson's, and Old Oyster Factory.

Enjoy scenic meals.

Private Chef Services

For vacation rental guests, hiring a private chef for an evening may create an unique luxury experience, bringing local flavors directly to your accommodation.

Personalized meals.

Food Festivals & Events

Seasonal Celebrations
Hilton Head Island Seafood Festival (February)
Hilton Head Island Wine & Food Festival (March)
Taste of the Lowcountry (various dates)
HarbourFest (Summer evenings)
Oyster Roasts (fall & winter)
Shrimp Season (late spring through fall)
Island-Style Casual Dining

Many spots hold a relaxed, beachy atmosphere, ideal for fresh seafood and outdoor drinks.

  • Casual and welcoming atmosphere.
  • Focus on fresh, local catches.
  • Outdoor seating options.
Street Food & Quick Bites

The traditional street food scene is limited. Local seafood markets offer fresh catches. Some casual beachside eateries present quick bites like fish tacos or crab cakes to go.

Not a prominent feature, but quick options exist.

Additional Dining Resources

Local Guides
  • Hilton Head Island Chamber of Commerce
  • Local tourism websites for updated dining lists.
Grocery Stores
  • Publix, Harris Teeter, and Kroger for self-catering supplies.
  • Specialty food stores for unique local products.

Further Culinary Information

Seasonal Dining

Festivals

Hilton Head Island offers various food festivals throughout the year, celebrating local seafood and wine. Check event calendars for specific dates.

Seafood Festival | Wine & Food Festival
Gullah Influences

Some eateries and tours highlight specific Gullah preparations and ingredients, like okra soup or red rice.

Seek out authentic Gullah flavors.
Breakfast & Brunch

Many local spots cater to early risers and brunch enthusiasts. Look for Southern breakfast staples.

Pancakes, waffles, and more.

Dining Tips & Local Insights

  • Peak Season Reservations: During high season, making dinner reservations well in advance is highly advisable to avoid long waits.
  • Explore Different Areas: Different neighborhoods like Harbour Town, Shelter Cove, and Coligny Plaza present distinct dining atmospheres and restaurant types.
  • Early Bird Specials: Many restaurants present early bird specials, usually before 6:00 PM, offering value for dinner.
  • Support Local Seafood: Look for restaurants that source their seafood locally for the freshest experience.

Food Safety & Quality

Quality Standards

Restaurants on Hilton Head Island generally keep high standards for food preparation and hygiene, aligning with state health regulations.

Dining establishments maintain cleanliness.

Customer Feedback

Review online feedback on platforms like TripAdvisor or Google Maps for insights into recent dining experiences.

Check reviews for current information.

Additional Culinary Activities

Local Produce

Visit local farmers markets for fresh, seasonal produce and artisanal goods, supporting regional agriculture.

Happy Hour Spots

Many restaurants and bars present happy hour specials, offering discounted drinks and appetizers, usually in the late afternoon.

Gullah Heritage

Seek out establishments or tours that explore Gullah cultural and culinary heritage for an unique historical and gastronomic experience.

Dining Tip

Always confirm operating hours and reservation policies, especially during holidays or special events.

  • Many restaurants close earlier than in larger cities.
  • Check for live music schedules at waterfront venues.
  • Consider carry-out or delivery options for casual nights in.
  • Ask locals for their favorite hidden gems.
  • Some venues may have seasonal closures or reduced hours in the off-season.