MileHacker Logo
Best Restaurants in Columbus

Best Restaurants in Columbus

Columbus Ohio, USA Travel Guide

Culinary Overview

Cultural Context & Ingredients

Columbus's cuisine blends traditional Midwestern comfort food with influences from its diverse immigrant populations and a modern emphasis on farm-to-table practices.

There is a great deal of importance placed on locally sourced produce, dairy, and meats, notably pork and beef, from Ohio farms. The city also has a thriving craft beer scene and independent coffee roasters.

Dining Customs and Etiquette

  • Casual Dining: Most restaurants are casual, but upscale establishments expect smart casual attire.
  • Tipping: Tipping (15-20%) is customary for table service staff.
  • Reservations: Recommended for fine dining, especially on weekends.
  • Splitting Checks: Generally accepted; inform your server early.

Regional Variations Within Columbus

German Village

Known for authentic German fare like bratwurst and schnitzel. Schmidt's Sausage Haus is an institution.

Short North Arts District

Features upscale American cuisine, international fusion, and innovative craft cocktail bars.

University District

Offers budget-friendly international options, especially Asian and West Asian, catering to students.

Meal Times and Structures

  • Breakfast: Typically 7:00 AM to 10:00 AM, often casual.
  • Lunch: Served 11:30 AM to 2:00 PM, from quick bites to sit-down meals.
  • Dinner: The main meal, 5:00 PM to 9:00 PM, featuring a lot of restaurants open later on weekends.
  • Brunch: A popular weekend activity, 10:00 AM to 2:00 PM, mixing breakfast and lunch items.

Must-Try Dishes

Signature Dishes & Treats

Ohio-style Chili

Often served over spaghetti, topped with shredded cheddar cheese, occasionally with beans and onions.

Find it at local diners and chili parlors.

Buckeye Candy

Creamy peanut butter fudge balls partially dipped in chocolate, resembling the buckeye nut.

Available at local candy shops, gift stores, and grocery stores.

Thurman Burger

An immense, multi-patty burger at the iconic Thurman Cafe in German Village.

Find it at Thurman Cafe, 183 Thurman Ave, Columbus, OH 43206.

Local Favorites

  • Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams: Artisanal frozen yogurt with unique, high-quality, and seasonal flavors. Find scoop shops throughout the city.
  • Street Food Trucks: A thriving scene offering gourmet tacos, grilled cheese, BBQ, and international fare, found downtown and at festivals.
  • Craft Beer: Columbus has many breweries like North High Brewing and Land-Grant Brewing Company.
  • Specialty Coffee: Strong independent the coffee scene with local roasters and specialty coffee shops.

Seasonal & Festival Foods

Columbus Jazz & Rib Fest July

Features various BBQ ribs and other grilled specialties from national vendors.

Harvest Festivals Fall

Look for pumpkin-flavored items, fresh apple cider, and apple cider donuts.

Dining Options

Fine Dining Establishments

For elegant dining experiences.

  • The Refectory (Classic French cuisine)
  • Chapman's Eat Market (Inventive New American)
  • Hyde Park Prime Steakhouse (High-quality steaks)

Mid-Range Restaurants

Quality food and ambiance at reasonable prices.

  • Northstar Cafe (Healthy, American-inspired)
  • Forno Kitchen + Bar (Italian-inspired tapas and pizzas)
  • Schmidt's Sausage Haus und Restaurant (Traditional German fare)

Budget Eateries & Markets

Delicious meals that do not break the bank.

  • Mobile Eateries (Various locations, check social media)
  • Ohio State University Area (Inexpensive ethnic restaurants)
  • North Market (Historic public market with diverse vendors)

International Cuisine Options

Strong Presence

Columbus has a choice of Mexican, Italian, Indian, Thai, Vietnamese, Korean, Japanese, Ethiopian, and Middle Eastern restaurants.

Many are found around the Global Mall and Saraga International Grocery on the north side.

Global Hubs

The area around Global Mall and Saraga International Grocery on the north side of the city offers a concentration of international food products and restaurants.

Explore this area for authentic culinary experiences.

Special Dietary Considerations

Vegetarian/Vegan

Many restaurants offer options, with dedicated establishments like Eden Burger.

Halal

Several restaurants and grocery stores cater to Halal diets.

Gluten-Free

Many restaurants and devoted bakeries accommodate gluten-free requests.

Resources

Apps like HappyCow, Yelp, and Google Maps offer filters for dietary options.

Culinary Experiences

Workshops and Classes

  • Cooking Classes: The Kitchen and Sur La Table offer hands-on classes for various cuisines.
  • Food Tours: Columbus Food Adventures offers guided walking tours with tastings and historical insights in neighborhoods like German Village and Short North.
  • Local Produce markets: North Market Farmers Market (seasonal), Clintonville, and Worthington Farmers Market for fresh produce and artisan goods.
  • Farm Tours: Some farms in surrounding rural areas offer seasonal tours or "U-pick" experiences.

Unique Dining Concepts

Dining in Historic Buildings

Experience meals in beautifully preserved historic structures, like The Thurman Cafe in German Village.

These spots offer an unique ambiance.

Repurposed Industrial Spaces

Many breweries and casual eateries in Franklinton are housed in creatively repurposed industrial buildings.

This provides a modern, edgy the atmosphere for dining.

Food Festivals and Events

Seasonal Delights
Columbus Food Truck Festival (August)
Taste of Summer/Winter (Restaurant week)
Columbus Jazz & Rib Fest (July)
Oktoberfest (September, German Village)
Ohio State Fair (July/August)
Harvest Celebrations (Fall)
Farm to Table Movement

Columbus chefs strongly emphasize ingredients from the area from Ohio farms.

  • Look for menu items highlighting local producers.
  • Visit farmers markets to meet growers.
  • This commitment ensures fresh, seasonal flavors.
Hidden Culinary Gems

Explore beyond the main districts to discover neighborhood eateries and "secret" speakeasy bars.

Ask locals for recommendations to find truly unique spots.

Further Resources for Dining in Columbus

Local Publications
  • Columbus Monthly
  • Columbus Underground
Community Groups
  • Local Facebook food groups
  • Reddit r/Columbus (for recommendations)

Special Dietary Considerations

Plant-Based Options

Vegetarian and Vegan Options

Many restaurants feature clearly marked vegetarian and vegan dishes.

Dedicated Restaurants: | Eden Burger, Seitan's Realm, Comune
Find more on HappyCow
Ethnic Cuisine for Vegans/Vegetarians

Indian, Ethiopian, Thai, and Middle Eastern restaurants are excellent choices for plant-based options.

Many dishes are naturally vegan or can be easily adapted.
Gluten-Free Dining

Many restaurants accommodate gluten-free requests, with some offering dedicated menus.

Dedicated gluten-free bakeries also can be found.

Religious Dietary Needs

  • Halal Availability: Several restaurants and grocery stores cater to Halal diets, particularly in areas with larger Muslim populations (e.g., Cleveland Avenue corridor).
  • Kosher Availability: Dedicated Kosher restaurants are limited, but Kosher products are available in major grocery stores. The Columbus Jewish Federation can provide resources.
  • Other Allergen-Aware Dining: Restaurants are accustomed to accommodating various dietary restrictions. Always inform your server when ordering.
  • Resources for Travelers: Use apps like HappyCow (vegan/vegetarian), Yelp, and Google Maps for filters. Restaurant websites often list allergen information.

Tips for Dietary Restrictions

Communicate Clearly

Always clearly state your dietary needs and allergies to restaurant staff, even if items are marked on the menu.

This helps ensure a safe dining experience.

Research Ahead

For specific or severe dietary needs, research dining places ahead of time or call ahead to discuss their capabilities.

Planning can save time and potential issues.

General Dining Advice

Be Polite

Restaurant staff are generally accommodating, and politeness makes the process smoother for everyone.

Allow Time

During peak hours, kitchens may be busy. Factor in extra time for meal preparation with special requests.

Confirm Order

When your food arrives, a quick confirmation with your server can avoid issues, especially for allergy-sensitive orders.

Remember to Tip

Tipping forms a significant portion of service staff's income in the United States.

  • Standard: 15-20% for good service.
  • Exceptional: 20%+ for outstanding service.
  • Delivery/Takeout: A smaller tip (10-15%) is appropriate for delivery drivers, and optional for takeout if no table service is provided.