MileHacker Logo
Best Restaurants in Outer Banks

Best Restaurants in Outer Banks

Outer Banks North Carolina, USA Travel Guide

Culinary Overview

Cultural Context & Ingredients

The Outer Banks culinary scene mirrors its identity as a coastal fishing community. Historically, islanders relied on ocean or sound catches, local crops, or mainland trade. This reliance fostered simple, delicious preparations highlighting seafood's natural flavors.

Seafood: The star of the Outer Banks plate. Common catches include shrimp, crabs (blue crabs), oysters, flounder, tuna, mahi-mahi, wahoo, scallops, and clams. Freshness is paramount. Flavors: Preparations are often simple to highlight seafood freshness, frequently fried, grilled, or steamed, seasoned with butter, lemon, and Old Bay.

Dining Customs & Meal Times

  • Breakfast: Typically served from 7 AM to 11 AM. Many cafes and diners serve breakfast.
  • Lunch: Generally available from 11 AM to 3 PM. Casual eateries and delis are popular.
  • Dinner: The main dining period, typically from 5 PM to 9 PM or 10 PM. Some restaurants close earlier in the off-season.
  • Tipping: Tipping for service is customary in the United States. 15-20% for good service is common.

Regional Variations

Northern OBX Corolla, Duck

These areas present more upscale dining and a broader diversity of cuisines, reflecting preferences for a refined experience.

Central OBX Kitty Hawk, Kill Devil Hills, Nags Head

This area holds the widest range of dining, from casual diners and family-style seafood restaurants to mid-range eateries.

Hatteras Island/Ocracoke

These southern areas present more authentic, local, and rustic seafood shacks and family-run eateries.

Dining Etiquette

  • Casual Atmosphere: Beachwear is acceptable for many daytime restaurants. For dinner, slightly nicer casual wear is common.
  • Reservations: Suggested for popular restaurants, especially during peak summer and on weekends.
  • Child-Friendly: Most restaurants are welcoming to families, with kids' menus.
  • Language: English is the official language.

Must-Try Dishes

Signature Dishes & Specialties

Fresh Seafood

Any preparation of locally caught fish (flounder, tuna, mahi-mahi), shrimp, oysters, or crabs. Look for "fresh catch of the day" specials. You find excellent fresh seafood at most restaurants.

Steamed Shrimp, Crab Legs/Crab Cakes, Oysters.

Hushpuppies & Fried Baskets

Small, savory fried cornmeal fritters, typically served as a complimentary side with almost any seafood meal. A classic casual meal found at many seafood shacks and diners.

Fried Fish/Shrimp Baskets.

She-Crab Soup & Carolina BBQ

A rich, creamy soup made with crab meat, a distinct flavor. A comforting appetizer. Eastern North Carolina BBQ (vinegar-based, pulled pork) is also found in some Outer Banks spots.

Slow-cooked, shredded pork.

Traditional Beverages

  • Sweet Tea: A quintessential Southern staple, widely available.
  • Craft Beer: The Outer Banks has a growing craft beer scene. Local breweries like Weeping Radish Farm Brewery and Outer Banks Brewing Station.
  • Local Wine: North Carolina has a growing wine industry, and you can find NC wines at some restaurants and shops.
  • Iconic snacks and desserts: Saltwater Taffy, Fudge, Lime Pie, Donuts (Duck Donuts).

Seasonal & Festival Foods

Soft Shell Crabs

A delicacy in spring and early summer when blue crabs shed their shells, typically fried and eaten whole.

Shrimp Season & Oyster Roasts

Peak shrimp season is late summer through early fall. Oyster roasts are popular social events in fall and winter, where oysters are steamed.

Dining Options

Fine Dining

Offers upscale, modern American cuisine with beautiful waterfront views.

  • Aqua Restaurant (Duck)
  • Blue Point (Duck)
  • Red Sky Cafe (Kitty Hawk)

Mid-Range Restaurants

A range of seafood and American cuisine options.

  • Owens' Restaurant (Nags Head)
  • Miller's Waterfront Restaurant (Nags Head)
  • Black Pelican Oceanfront Restaurant (Kitty Hawk)

Budget & Street Food

Affordable meals and quick bites.

  • Fish Markets/Take-Out (Whalebone Seafood)
  • Diners/Casual Spots (Pizza, subs, burgers)
  • Food Trucks (at events or popular spots)

Markets & International Cuisine

Local Seafood Markets

Best places to buy fresh, locally caught seafood. Many offer steaming services. Examples: Wanchese Fish Company, O'Neal's Sea Harvest.

Farmers Markets are seasonal in various towns, offering local produce and baked goods.

International Cuisine Options

Present but limited. You find Italian, Mexican, Chinese, and Japanese (sushi) restaurants, mainly in the northern and central towns.

More diverse options are available in larger cities on the mainland.

Special Dietary Considerations

Vegetarian & Vegan

Many restaurants offer adaptions; review menus online or call ahead.

Gluten-Free & Allergens

Some restaurants accommodate; always inform your server of allergies.

Halal & Kosher

Options are very limited. Self-catering from supermarkets may be needed.

Resources

Use apps like HappyCow or contact restaurants directly.

Culinary Experiences

Hands-on Culinary Experiences

  • Cooking Classes: Some local chefs offer seafood-focused classes, especially during shoulder seasons.
  • Food Tours: Formal food tours are limited. Some walking tours of Manteo or Duck may incorporate food tastings.
  • Farm Visits: Direct farm visits on the barrier islands are limited. Local seafood markets source from regional fishermen.
  • "Pick Your Own" Seafood: Some markets allow you to select live crabs or shellfish, which they steam on-site for a fresh experience.

Unique Dining Concepts

Soundside Dining

Many restaurants present stunning sunset views over the Pamlico Sound. Dining while watching the sun dip below the horizon is a memorable Outer Banks experience.

Oceanfront Dining: A different ambiance with waves and sea breezes.

Food Festivals & Events

Outer Banks Seafood Festival: An annual event in October celebrating local seafood. Taste of the Beach: A spring culinary event. Check local event calendars for smaller community food events.

Oyster roasts are popular in the fall/winter.

Popular Food Trucks

Street Food Specialties
Fish Tacos
Gourmet Hot Dogs
BBQ Sandwiches
Soft-Serve Ice Cream
Cookies & Baked Goods
Saltwater Taffy
Grocery Store Availability

Food Lion and Harris Teeter are the main grocery chains on the Outer Banks, well-stocked for all your self-catering needs.

  • For a truly local experience, visit a seafood market, buy some fresh catch, and prepare it in your vacation rental's kitchen.
  • It is delicious and often more economical.
No Formal "Street Food" Culture

The Outer Banks does not have a formal "street food" culture akin to larger cities.

However, during peak season, you might find casual food trucks at events or popular spots.

Other Local Information

Affiliate Resources
More Affiliate Resources
Additional Affiliate Resources

General Information

Dining Spots & Experiences

Paper Canoe Manns Harbor

Located on the mainland side just before Roanoke Island, this restaurant has exceptional fine dining with stunning sound views, popular for sunset.

Cuisine: Fine Dining | Views: Soundside Sunset
Dirty Dick's Crab House

A lively spot known for its steamed seafood, including crab legs and shrimp, served in a fun, casual atmosphere in Nags Head and Kitty Hawk.

Atmosphere: Casual, Lively
Sugar Creek Seafood Restaurant and Market

Offers both prepared seafood dishes and fresh seafood for purchase. A local option for enjoying and preparing seafood.

Type: Restaurant & Market

Dining Details

  • The freshness of the seafood is paramount for a great experience.
  • Casual and relaxed dining atmosphere.
  • Reservations are important for popular spots.
  • Craft Beer and Local Wine options are growing.

Other Specific Mentions

Wanchese Fish Company

A local seafood market where you can purchase fresh, local seafood.

Great for cooking at your rental.

O'Neal's Sea Harvest

Another excellent local seafood market with fresh catches and take-out options.

Offers steamed items for quick meals.

Culinary Tip

Local Experience

For a truly local experience, visit a seafood market, purchase some fresh catch, and prepare it in your vacation rental's kitchen. It's delicious and often more economical.

Fresh Seafood Focus

The Outer Banks cuisine prioritizes fresh, locally sourced ingredients, especially from the surrounding waters. Look for daily specials.

Local Beverages

Don't forget to try Sweet Tea, a Southern staple, and explore the growing craft beer scene with local breweries.

General Information

The Outer Banks culinary scene blends coastal heritage with Southern comfort food, creating distinct and inviting local cuisine.

  • The connection to the water is not just about sustenance; it is a way of life, seen in every dish.
  • Produce from mainland North Carolina provides seasonal offerings.
  • Reservations are generally suggested for dining during peak season.
  • Tipping 15-20% for service is standard.
  • Most restaurants are family-friendly.