MileHacker Logo
Best Restaurants in Staten Island

Best Restaurants in Staten Island

Staten Island New York, USA Travel Guide

Culinary Overview

Cultural & Historical Context

One Of new york city's five boroughs is a potent Italian-American heritage, profoundly shaping its culinary scene. Generations of Italian immigrants established bakeries, delis, and restaurants.

Beyond this, as a melting pot of cultures, Staten Island's dining options represent a growing array of other ethnic cuisines.

Meal Times

  • Breakfast: Typically 7 AM to 10 AM. Many delis and diners.
  • Lunch: Generally NOON to 2 PM. Lunch specials are common.
  • Dinner: Usually 6 PM to 9 PM. Often extends later on weekends.
  • Dining patterns are generally casual.

Ingredients & Flavors

Italian Staples

Fresh pasta, robust tomato sauces, generous use of garlic, olive oil, and high-quality cheeses.

Seafood

Access to fresh seafood from surrounding waters often brings appealing fish and shellfish options.

NYC Influence

Classic deli meats, fresh bagels, and diverse spices from across the globe.

Dining Customs & Etiquette

  • Tipping: 15-20% for good service is customary.
  • Seating: Wait to be seated by a host at sit-down restaurants.
  • Ordering: Servers often take drink orders first.
  • Splitting the Bill: Inform your server early for larger groups.

Must-Try Dishes

Iconic Staten Island Eats

New York-Style Pizza

Ubiquitous and a must-try. Staten Island boasts many highly-rated pizzerias.

Seek an iconic, thin-crust slice with a crisp crust and flavorful sauce.

Italian-American Comfort Food

Dive into classic meals made with pasta, savory meatballs, chicken parmigiana, or baked ziti.

Family-owned Italian eateries frequently excel at these hearty, traditional preparations.

Bagels and Cream Cheese

A classic New York breakfast. Find freshly baked bagels at local shops.

Accompanied by a generous schmear of cream cheese and your choice of toppings.

Other Culinary Delights

  • Deli Sandwiches: Large, fresh sandwiches piled high with quality meats and cheeses.
  • Cheesecake: Experience the rich, dense, and creamy New York-style cheesecake.
  • Street Food: Hot dogs, pretzels, and sometimes specialized ethnic foods at events.
  • Pastries: Indulge in treats from a local Italian bakery.

Beverages & Desserts

Coffee

Widely consumed. Find independent coffee shops and major chains.

Craft Beer

A growing number of local breweries and craft beer bars.

Dining Options

Fine Dining

Dedicated fine-dining restaurants are limited compared to Manhattan.

  • Some upscale Italian or American restaurants.
  • Offering refined menus and elevated service.
  • Research these for celebrations.

Mid-Range Restaurants

This category is abundant, presenting a wide variety of choices.

  • Find varied cuisines including Italian, American, Mexican.
  • Also Chinese, Japanese, and Of indian origin restaurants.
  • Comfortable settings and good value.

Budget Eateries & Street Food

Delis, pizza shops, diners, and fast-casual restaurants.

  • Quick, affordable, and satisfying meals.
  • Perfect for everyday eating or grab-and-go.
  • Food trucks appear at events.

International Cuisine

Diverse Options

The borough boasts strong representation of Italian, Mexican, Chinese, Japanese, Indian, and West Asian cuisines.

Explore these for authentic and flavorful experiences.

Special Dietary Needs

Vegetarian & Vegan

Widely available; many restaurants adapt dishes.

Halal & Kosher

Some specialized restaurants; supermarkets carry products.

Gluten-Free

Many restaurants accommodate; inform your server.

Allergen-Aware

NYC restaurants are accustomed; communicate needs.

Culinary Experiences

Beyond eating, Staten Island offers ways to immerse yourself in its food culture.

Local Culinary Engagements

  • Cooking Classes: Occasional workshops at local businesses or community centers.
  • Food Tours: Plentiful in Manhattan and Brooklyn.
  • Farmers Markets: Staten Island Greenmarket (seasonal).
  • Farm Visits: Limited on Staten Island, focus on local markets.

Festival & Dining Spots

Food Festivals & Events

Keep an eye on local One Of new york city's five boroughs event calendars for food festivals or block parties.

These feature local eateries and specialties.

Unique Waterfront Dining

Some waterfront restaurants deliver delicious food.

They also have unique views of the New York Harbor or the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge.

Dining Resources

Finding Specific Options
Halal
Kosher
Organic
Vegetarian
Vegan
Gluten-Free
Dietary Apps

Apps like HappyCow (vegan/vegetarian) or Yelp (filter capabilities) locate suitable restaurants.

  • HappyCow
  • Yelp
  • Gluten-Free Passport
Local Recommendations

When dining out, ask local people for their favorite spots. They often know the best hidden gems and family-run establishments.

Local insights enrich your culinary journey.

Additional Culinary Links

Restaurant Guides
Food Blogs
  • Local Staten Island food blogs
  • Foodie guides for NYC boroughs
Cooking Resources
  • NYC cooking schools
  • Online recipe resources

Essential Dining Tips

Be ready for diverse flavors and dining experiences on Staten Island.

  • Confirm hours of operation, especially for smaller, family-run establishments.
  • Reservations are advisable for upscale restaurants, especially on weekends.
  • Explore beyond Italian cuisine; the borough features several ethnic options.
  • Carry cash for smaller delis or food stands, though card payments are widespread.
  • Stay hydrated, especially during summer months.
Best Restaurants in Staten Island. Food, Dining, Local Cuisine