MileHacker Logo
Where to Stay in Finger Lakes

Where to Stay in Finger Lakes

Finger Lakes New York, USA Travel Guide

Local Flavors and Heritage

Ingredients

  • Produce:

    Apples are a major crop, alongside grapes for wine and juice. Seasonal vegetables, berries, corn, squash, and pumpkins are found at farm stands.

  • Dairy:

    High-quality milk, cheese, and yogurt from local creameries characterize artisanal cheese producers.

  • Proteins:

    Local beef, pork, and poultry appear on menus. Freshwater fish hold historical culinary significance.

  • Beverages:

    Renowned wines (Riesling, Gewürztraminer), craft beers, hard ciders, and distilled spirits.

Regional Culinary Variations

  • Ithaca:

    A diverse, internationally influenced dining scene due to its university population. Global cuisines appear alongside local fare.

  • Smaller Towns:

    Focus on classic American comfort food, family-friendly diners, and charming lakeside dining options.

  • Wine Country:

    Restaurants feature menus designed to pair with local wines, offering a harmonious culinary experience.

  • Dining Customs:

    Standard American dining etiquette applies. 15-20% for service is customary for waitstaff.

Finger Lakes Signature Tastes

Indulge in the distinct flavors of the Finger Lakes, from world-class wines to unique local treats.

Regional Wines

Celebrate
  • Dry, semi-dry, and sweet Rieslings
  • Gewürztraminer, Chardonnay
  • Pinot Noir, Cabernet Franc
  • Each wine trail offers unique expressions
Experience
  • Taste varieties on the wine trails
  • Consider booking a tour to visit multiple wineries
  • Pair with local cuisine
  • Learn about the winemaking process

Artisanal Cheeses

Discover
  • Sample cheeses from local dairies
  • Lively Run Dairy
  • Muranda Cheese Company
  • Farm visits and tastings often available
Pairings
  • Excellent with Finger Lakes wines
  • Serve with local honey or fruit
  • Enjoy on charcuterie boards
  • Taste different aged varieties

Orchard Fresh Apples

Enjoy
  • Freshly pressed apple cider (sweet and hard)
  • Homemade apple pies
  • Apple donuts
  • Apple butter
Where to Find
  • Farm stands
  • Local bakeries
  • Especially abundant in the fall season
  • U-pick orchards also available

Seasonal Delights

Fall Flavors:

Expect all things apple and pumpkin-spiced. Grape harvest-related foods are prominent, notably around the Naples Grape Festival.

Winter Specialties:

Seek out "ice wine," a sweet dessert wine from grapes frozen on the vine, an unique regional product.

Local Drinks & Sweet Treats

Beyond renowned wines, explore a dynamic craft beverage scene and beloved regional desserts.

Craft Beverages

  • Finger Lakes Wine: Diverse varietals beyond Riesling.
  • Craft Beer: Numerous breweries with diverse styles.
  • Hard Cider: Often made from local apples.
  • Distilled Spirits: Bourbons, gins, and vodkas from local grains.

Non-Alcoholic Refreshments

  • Freshly pressed apple cider is a seasonal favorite.
  • Local fruit juices from grapes or other berries.
  • Local coffee roasters and tea houses are available.
  • Handcrafted sodas can also be found.

Dessert Specialties

Grape Pie:
  • A regional specialty, especially around Naples, New York.
  • Celebrates the Concord grape harvest.
  • A sweet, tangy, unique local treat.
  • Available at local bakeries, specifically in fall.
Local Ice Cream:
  • Many creameries and farm stores feature homemade ice cream.
  • Often uses local dairy and fruit.
  • Look for seasonal flavors.
  • A refreshing treat, especially in summer.

Dining Customs & Tips

Tipping:

15-20% for good service is customary for waitstaff.

Reservations:

Recommended for popular restaurants, especially on weekends and during peak season (summer, fall).

Dress Code:

Generally casual for most eateries. Some upscale restaurants may suggest "smart casual" attire.

Explore Dining Choices

The Finger Lakes region caters to all dining preferences, from casual to upscale.

Refined Dining

Winery Restaurants

Many upscale restaurants are found at wineries, offering refined menus with curated wine pairings.

  • Dano's Heuriger on Seneca (Seneca Lake)
  • Kindred Fare (Geneva)
  • Often feature vineyard views
Upscale Town Eateries

High-end restaurants also appear in towns like Skaneateles, Ithaca, and Canandaigua.

  • The Bistro at Mirbeau (Skaneateles)
  • John Thomas Steakhouse (Ithaca)
  • Reservations highly suggested

Casual Eateries

Mid-Range Options

Abundant across the region, offering diverse cuisines.

  • American bistros
  • Italian restaurants
  • Many casual eateries in town centers
Global & Local Flavors

Find a range of dining experiences for various tastes.

  • Mexican cuisine
  • Asian dining options
  • Casual cafes and pubs

Affordable Bites

  • Diners & Cafes:

    Local diners, casual cafes, and pizza places provide quick, affordable meals.

  • Food Trucks:

    Occasional food trucks appear at festivals, farmers' markets, or in larger town centers.

  • Farmers' Markets:

    The Ithaca Farmers Market, among others, offers excellent value with fresh, prepared foods.

  • Grocery Stores:

    Major grocery stores like Wegmans and Tops are available for self-catering.

Markets and Global Flavors

  • Ithaca Farmers Market:

    Open seasonally, offering local produce, baked goods, and prepared foods from various vendors.

  • Local Farm Stands:

    Common in rural areas, selling fresh produce directly from the farm.

  • International Cuisine:

    Most prevalent in Ithaca due to its university population, with a range of global cuisines.

  • Specialty Food Shops:

    Discover gourmet items, local delicacies, and artisanal products.

Special Dietary Needs

Vegetarian & Vegan Options

These options grow in availability in restaurants, especially in Ithaca. Most mid-range and fine dining establishments can accommodate vegetarian and often vegan requests.

  • Check online menus
  • Review restaurant offerings
  • Call ahead for specific details
Gluten-Free & Allergen-Aware

Many restaurants can accommodate dietary restrictions. Always inform your server of any allergies or dietary needs for guidance or modifications.

  • Communicate with staff
  • Look for menu labels
  • Seek out dedicated gluten-free eateries if needed

Culinary Experiences & Resources

Cooking Classes & Food Tours

Some wineries or culinary schools offer classes on regional cuisine. Food tours highlight local eateries and specialties in Ithaca and other towns.

Farm Visits & Food Producers

Many farms provide farm stands for direct purchases. Some allow tours or have "pick-your-own" opportunities, like apple orchards in fall or berry farms in summer.

Unique Dining Concepts

Lakeside dining options feature scenic views and a relaxed atmosphere, especially during warmer months.