MileHacker Logo
Getting Around Finger Lakes

Getting Around Finger Lakes

Finger Lakes New York, USA Travel Guide

General Accommodation Overview

Hostels: Very limited, mainly in Ithaca. Motels: Budget-friendly choices along major routes. Hotels: Chain (Holiday Inn, Hampton Inn) and independent hotels in larger towns like Ithaca, Geneva, Canandaigua.

Bed & Breakfasts (B&Bs) / Inns: A signature accommodation type in the Finger Lakes. Often historic homes, providing personalized service, gourmet breakfasts, and unique charm. Widely available near wine trails for an intimate local experience.

Specialized Lodging

  • Boutique Hotels: Smaller, stylish hotels with unique design elements in popular towns like Skaneateles, Geneva, Ithaca.
  • Resorts: A few larger resorts with extensive amenities like golf courses, spas, multiple dining options. Examples: The Lake House on Canandaigua, Mirbeau Inn & Spa.
  • Winery Stays: Some wineries offer on-site guest rooms or cottages for an immersive vineyard experience.
  • Glamping: Upscale camping experiences with furnished tents or cabins at state parks or private sites.

Vacation Rentals

Abundant throughout the region on platforms like Airbnb and VRBO. Options range from rustic lakeside cottages to spacious homes. Ideal for families, groups, or longer stays.

Homestay & Community

Less formal homestays via platforms like Airbnb, where you rent a room in a local's home. The region does not have a distinct "community-based tourism" program that formally integrates visitors into local village life.

Camping

State Parks like Watkins Glen, Taughannock Falls, and Robert H. Treman offer campgrounds. Reservations through the NY State Parks website are highly recommended, especially during summer and fall.

Booking Strategies

Advance Planning
  • For peak seasons (Summer, Fall foliage), booking 3-6 months in advance is highly recommended.
  • Popular B&Bs, unique rentals, and prime lakefront properties book quickly.
  • For off-peak travel, 1-2 months is usually sufficient for booking.
Platforms & Policies
  • Trusted Platforms: Booking.com and Expedia for hotels/B&Bs; Airbnb and VRBO for vacation rentals.
  • Direct Bookings: Many B&Bs and independent hotels encourage direct bookings via their websites; they may have special deals.
  • Deposit and Cancellation Policies: These vary widely; review specific policies before confirming your booking.

Accommodation Recommendations

Budget Travelers

Motels ($70-$150) or State Park Campgrounds ($20-$50). Ideal for short stays or outdoor enthusiasts.

Mid-Range Options

B&Bs/Inns ($150-$300), Mid-range Hotels ($120-$250), or smaller vacation rentals ($100-$300). Good for couples or families.

Luxury Choices

Boutique Hotels ($350-$600+) or Luxury Vacation Rentals ($400-$1000+). Ideal for special occasions or large groups.

Family-Friendly

Vacation rentals with kitchens or chain hotels with pools. State Park campgrounds offer outdoor activities.

Neighborhood Guide

The Finger Lakes region is large, with each lake and its surrounding communities possessing a slightly different character.

Ithaca & Canandaigua

  • Ithaca: Intellectual, liberal, and naturally beautiful. Home to Cornell University and Ithaca College.
  • Ithaca Pros: Stunning waterfalls and gorges, thriving creative community, diverse food scene. Excellent public transport (TCAT).
  • Ithaca Cons: Can be crowded during academic semesters. Limited urban amenities compared to major cities.
  • Ithaca Proximity: Central to Cayuga Lake and its wine trail. A good base for exploring southern Finger Lakes.

Geneva & Watkins Glen

  • Geneva (Seneca Lake): Charming lakeside city, known for its active culinary and wine scene. Gateway to the Seneca Lake Wine Trail.
  • Geneva Cons: Can be busy, especially on weekends during peak wine season.
  • Geneva Proximity: Central on Seneca Lake, easy access to both sides of the wine trail. Close to Cayuga Lake.
  • Watkins Glen: Famous for its state park with stunning gorges and waterfalls. Quaint downtown. Southern end of Seneca Lake Wine Trail.

Corning & Skaneateles

  • Corning: "Crystal City," home to the Corning Museum of Glass and The Rockwell Museum. Charming historic downtown (Market Street).
  • Corning Cons: Not directly on a Finger Lake, needs a drive to reach major lakes.
  • Corning Proximity: Good hub for exploring the southern part of the region and nearby wine regions.
  • Skaneateles: Picturesque village on tranquil Skaneateles Lake. Known for sophisticated charm, boutique shops, and beautiful architecture.
  • Skaneateles Cons: Can be expensive. Limited lodging options.
  • Skaneateles Vibe: Highly walkable downtown, upscale dining and shopping, beautiful lakefront.

Security Considerations by Area

Overall Safety

The Finger Lakes region is generally safe across all neighborhoods. Crime rates are low.

Common Issues

Most common issues are petty theft, like car break-ins if valuables are left visible.

Prevention

Always lock your car doors and hotel rooms. Be aware of your surroundings, especially at night in more populated areas like downtown Ithaca. No specific "no-go" areas.

Properties with Cultural or Historical Significance

Discover lodging with unique charm and a rich past, contributing to an immersive experience.

Inns of Aurora Aurora

  • A collection of historic, luxury inns on Cayuga Lake.
  • Offers refined experiences in beautifully restored properties.
  • Known for high-end amenities and exquisite design.
  • Dining experiences and a spa complement the stay.

Belhurst Castle Geneva

  • A historic castle on Seneca Lake.
  • Provides hotel rooms, a spa, and restaurants within an unique, grand setting.
  • Its location on Seneca Lake offers beautiful views.
  • Many individual B&Bs throughout the region are located in beautifully restored historic homes.

Noise Levels and Ambiance

Lakeside Properties

Can offer tranquil settings with scenic views of the water.

May hear occasional boat traffic during busy periods.

Town Centers

Will have more ambient noise from restaurants, shops, and general activities.

Livelier atmosphere, especially during evenings.

Rural Accommodations

Offer peace and quiet, often surrounded by vineyards or natural landscapes.

Few disturbances, ideal for relaxation.

Accommodation Comparison Table

Budget & Mid-Range
  • Motels: $70 - $150. Affordable, basic amenities, good for overnight stops. Less character, limited facilities.
  • State Park Campgrounds: $20 - $50. Immersive nature, very affordable. Basic facilities, needs Camping gear, seasonal.
  • B&Bs/Inns: $150 - $300. Charming, personalized service, breakfast included. Less private, book ahead.
Luxury & Vacation Rentals
  • Mid-range Hotels: $120 - $250. Reliable quality, standard amenities, good locations. Less unique charm.
  • Vacation Rentals (Smaller/Rural): $100 - $300. More space, kitchens, local experience. No daily service, can be isolated.
  • Boutique/Luxury Hotels: $350 - $600+. High-end amenities, exquisite design, prime locations. Expensive, book far in advance.

Important Booking Notes

  • Seasonal Price Fluctuations: Accommodation prices may double or triple during peak season (fall foliage, summer weekends) compared to low season.
  • Negotiation Customs for Walk-in Rates: Not customary in the U.S. To negotiate walk-in rates for established hotels or B&Bs. Prices are generally fixed.
  • Solo Traveler Recommendations: Ithaca has hostels and a walkable downtown. B&Bs connect you with hosts and guests.
  • Long-Stay Accommodations: Vacation rentals are best for extended stays, offering home comforts and cost savings on meals.
  • Choosing Accommodation by Location: If focusing on a specific wine trail, choose accommodation near that lake.
  • For Seneca Lake wineries, stay in Geneva, Watkins Glen, or Romulus.
  • For Cayuga Lake, Ithaca or Aurora are excellent choices.
  • Remember that smaller towns may have limited lodging options.

Family-Friendly Options

The Finger Lakes region is an excellent destination for families, with a variety of activities and accommodations suitable for all ages.

Space & Amenities

  • Vacation rentals with multiple bedrooms and kitchens are ideal for families, providing ample space.
  • The ability to prepare meals in a rental can offer cost savings and dietary flexibility.
  • Chain hotels with amenities like pools (e.g., Hampton Inn in Ithaca) provide entertainment for children.
  • State Park campgrounds offer outdoor activities and a chance to connect with nature.

Activities & Convenience

  • Many state parks have family-friendly trails suitable for different fitness levels.
  • Lake activities like swimming, kayaking, and boat tours are popular in summer.
  • Museums like the Corning Museum of Glass offer engaging experiences for children.

Solo Traveler Recommendations

Ithaca

Ithaca has the most options for solo travelers.

  • Limited hostels available.
  • Walkable downtown with cafes and cultural activities.
  • Good public transport (TCAT).
Bed & Breakfasts

B&Bs can be good for solo travelers.

  • Connect with hosts and other guests.
  • Offer a sense of community.
  • Often include breakfast.
Outdoor Activities

The region is safe for solo outdoor exploration.

  • Hiking trails in state parks.
  • Kayaking or paddleboarding on the lakes.
  • Photography opportunities.

Long-Stay Accommodations

Vacation Rentals
  • Vacation rentals are best for extended stays.
  • Offer the comforts of home, including kitchens for self-catering.
  • Contribute to cost savings on meals over a longer period.
Considerations
  • Many vacation rentals may have minimum stay requirements, especially during peak season.
  • Location choices: Rural for quiet, town centers for amenities.
  • Ensure the rental includes all necessary utilities and Wi-Fi for comfort.

General Accommodation Tips

Smart booking practices help secure your preferred accommodation and potentially save money. Be aware of seasonal price fluctuations.

Booking Platforms

  • Booking.com and Expedia offer a wide selection of hotels and B&Bs.
  • Airbnb and VRBO are excellent for vacation rentals.
  • Book your accommodation well in advance, especially during peak seasons (Summer, Fall foliage).
  • Direct bookings with B&Bs and independent hotels may offer special deals or personalized service.

Price Considerations

  • Accommodation prices can double or triple during peak season compared to the low season.
  • Travel in shoulder or low season to find lower prices on accommodations.
  • Always review the specific deposit and cancellation policies before confirming your booking.
  • It is not customary to negotiate walk-in rates for established hotels or B&Bs in the U.S.

Strategic Location

If your visit focuses on a specific wine trail, choose accommodation near that particular lake for ease of access and travel.

Wine Trail Focus

For Seneca Lake wineries, staying in towns like Geneva, Watkins Glen, or Romulus provides convenient access to numerous vineyards.

Lake-Specific Bases

For exploring the Cayuga Lake Wine Trail, Ithaca or Aurora are excellent choices as a base, offering both town amenities and vineyard proximity.

Properties with Exceptional Cultural or Historical Significance

Inns of Aurora Aurora
  • A collection of historic, luxury inns on Cayuga Lake.
  • Offers refined experiences in beautifully restored properties.
  • Complements stays with high-end amenities and exquisite design.
Belhurst Castle Geneva
  • A historic castle on Seneca Lake, offering hotel rooms.
  • Includes a spa and restaurants within an unique, grand setting.
  • Many individual B&Bs are located in beautifully restored historic homes.

Helpful Tip

If you plan on extensive wine tasting, consider booking a private wine tour or using a designated driver.

This approach safety and allows everyone to fully enjoy the region's renowned wines.