MileHacker Logo
Best Restaurants in Buffalo

Best Restaurants in Buffalo

Buffalo New York, USA Travel Guide

Culinary Overview

Cultural and Historical Context

Buffalo’s culinary story began with its position as a grain and transportation center, leading to a focus on substantial meals for its industrial workforce.

Immigrant populations, notably from Italy, Poland, and Germany, brought their traditions, creating comforting and flavorful dishes. The Buffalo wing arose from this point environment.

Ingredients and Flavors

  • Chicken: For the famous wings.
  • Beef: Specifically for the iconic beef on weck.
  • Local Produce: Western New York’s agricultural bounty, seasonal.
  • Cheese: Blue cheese, often with wings. Locally produced cheeses also appear.

Dining Customs

Reservations

For fine dining, reservations are recommended on weekends. For casual places, they are generally not needed but useful during peak hours.

Dress Code

Casual dress is fine in the majority of locations. For fine dining, smart casual or business casual attire works.

Tipping

Tipping remains customary, typically 15-20% for good service.

Meal Times

  • Breakfast: Typically 7 AM to 10 AM.
  • Lunch: Generally NOON to 2 PM.
  • Dinner: Most restaurants begin dinner service around 5 PM or 6 PM, with the highest dining from 6 PM to 9 PM.
  • Some restaurants and bars have extended hours, especially on weekends.

Must-Try Dishes

Signature Dishes

Buffalo Wings

Fried chicken wing sections coated in a cayenne pepper hot sauce and butter mixture. Served with blue cheese dressing and celery sticks.

Find them at: Anchor Bar, Duff's Famous Wings, Gabriel's Gate.

Beef on Weck

Thinly sliced, rare roast beef on a kummelweck roll (Kaiser roll with caraway seeds and coarse salt). Served au jus and with horseradish.

Find them at: Schwabl's Restaurant, Charlie the Butcher's Kitchen, Bar-Bill Tavern (East Aurora).

Sponge Candy

A distinctive local confection: brittle, aerated sugary candy with a honeycomb-like texture, often coated in chocolate.

Find them at: Park Edge Sweet Shoppe, Fowler's Chocolates, Watson's Chocolates.

Local Beverages and Snacks

  • Local Breweries: Numerous local breweries include taprooms for sampling a range of beers.
  • Loganberry: A local cult-favorite non-alcoholic beverage, sweet and fruity. You can find it in many local diners and mini-marts.

Iconic Snacks and Desserts

Buffalo-Style Pizza

Distinct from New York or Chicago styles. It often includes a sweeter sauce, a medium-thick crust, and "cup-and-char" pepperoni.

Costanzo's Rolls

These rolls are widely used for subs and beef on weck. Their specific texture and taste add to the genuineity.

Dining Options

Fine Dining

For a sophisticated culinary experience, Buffalo includes acclaimed fine dining restaurants with refined menus and elegant ambiance.

  • Oliver's: Upscale Food from the usa, classic ambiance.
  • Hutch's: Sophisticated American bistro, seasonal menu.
  • Patina 250: Modern American cuisine, stylish design.

Mid-Range Restaurants

This category includes a wide array of options, with quality food and atmosphere at approachable prices.

  • Resurgence Brewing Company: Craft beers, gastropub fare.
  • Big Ditch Brewing Company: Diverse menu, lively taproom.
  • Gabriel's Gate: Iconic spot, pub grub.

Budget Eateries

For affordable and casual dining, Buffalo provides many choices.

  • Diners and Casual Sandwich Shops.
  • Mobile Eateries: Common at events, Canalside, Larkin Square.
  • Local Pizzerias: Serve Buffalo-style pizza.

International Cuisine Options

Diverse Culinary Heritage

Buffalo’s immigrant heritage translates to a rich selection of international cuisines.

Family-owned Italian restaurants, Polish delis, Vietnamese, Mexican, Middle Eastern, and other Asian and Latin American cuisines are well-represented.

Markets and Food Halls

Broadway Market

Historic city market, variety of vendors.

West Side Bazaar

(Currently relocating) International food court and market.

Lexington Co-op Markets

Organic and locally sourced groceries, prepared foods.

Special Dietary Considerations

Vegetarian and Vegan Options

  • Many restaurants, especially in Themwood Village plus the central area, include clearly marked vegetarian and vegan options.
  • Chefs often adapt dishes to encounter these requirements.

Halal and Kosher Availability

Halal Options

Dedicated Halal restaurants are limited, yet some international eateries sometimes include Halal options.

Ask directly restaurants for specific needs.

Kosher Food

For Kosher food, specialty grocery stores sometimes carry officially approved goods.

Direct inquiries to restaurants are recommended for specific requirements.

Allergen-Aware Dining

Common Allergies
Wheat-based foods
Tree nuts
Dairy products
Fish and shellfish
Eggs
Soy
Restaurant Accommodations

Many restaurants in Buffalo are aware of common allergies and can accommodate requests.

  • Always inform your server about any dietary restrictions or allergies when you order.
  • They guide you through the menu and consult with the kitchen.
Resources for Travelers

Use apps like HappyCow (for vegan/vegetarian) or Find Me Gluten Free to discover suitable restaurants.

For intricate or severe allergies, calling restaurants ahead of time allows them to confirm if they can fulfill your needs. Many menus are online.

Culinary Experiences

Cooking Classes and Food Tours
Farm Visits and Producers
  • Western New York has a rich agrithe cultural environment.
  • During summer and fall, many farms and orchards include seasonal picking.
Food Festivals and Events
  • The Taste of Buffalo (July).
  • Buffalo Wing Festival (annual event).

Unique Dining Concepts

Signature Experiences

Experiencing Buffalo Wings at the Anchor Bar

A cultural pilgrimage for numerous tourists, tasting the original Buffalo wing.

Real Atmosphere Historic Significance
Visit the Original
Visiting a Local Brewery Taproom

The craft beer scene has boomed in Buffalo, having lots of breweries offering taprooms.

Local Brews
Dining in Larkinville

This formerly industrial area includes a modern dining experience within a historic setting.

Revitalized District

Street Food Specialties

  • Buffalo does not include a traditional, extensive street food market.
  • Food trucks grew in popularity, specifically during warmer months.
  • Find them at events, at Canalside, or at Larkin Square.
  • These trucks include a variety of cuisines, from gourmet burgers to tacos and fusion dishes.

Seasonal and Festival Foods

The Taste of Buffalo

This big outdoor food festival takes place in July. It features numerous local eateries offering sample-sized portions.

An excellent opportunity to try a wide range of Buffalo cuisine in one place.

Buffalo Wing Festival

An annual event dedicated entirely to the city's famous dish, drawing wing enthusiasts from everywhere.

Check specific dates before planning.

Local Insights

Ask Locals

Do not be afraid to ask locals for their favorite places to eat. Buffalonians are proud of their food scene.

Authentic Recommendations

Residents frequently provide excellent, authentic recommendations beyond popular tourist spots.

Community Pride

The city's food culture mirrors a strong sense of community and local pride.

Helpful Dining Tip

Beyond signature dishes, explore Buffalo's diverse neighborhoods for hidden culinary gems.

  • Elmwood Village for independent cafes and bistros.
  • Allentown for quirky pubs plus live performances venues.
  • The West Side for emerging global cuisines.
  • Larkinville for modern brewpubs and eateries.
  • Food festivals provide a sampling of the urban area-wide flavors.