MileHacker Logo
Best Restaurants in Catskills

Best Restaurants in Catskills

Catskills New York State, USA Travel Guide

Culinary Overview

Cultural & Historical Context

Historically, the Catskills gained fame for its "Borscht Belt" resorts, specifically in Sullivan County. These resorts provided large, often Kosher-style meals, serving generations of vacationing families.

Today, the culinary identity embraces local farms, artisan producers, and diverse ethnic influences. Chefs from New York City bring diverse culinary backgrounds and a passion for local sourcing, resulting in a dynamic food scene.

Ingredients & Flavors

  • Local Produce: Seasonal vegetables and fruits, notably apples and berries, are prominent.
  • Maple Syrup: A local delicacy, it flavors many dishes, from breakfast to desserts and savory glazes.
  • Meats & Dairy: Locally raised beef, pork, poultry, artisan cheeses, and fresh milk are common.
  • Wild Game & Fish: Freshly caught trout often appears on menus, and venison is featured seasonally.

Regional Variations

Livingston Manor

The strongest hub for craft beverages, featuring multiple breweries and distilleries.

Woodstock & Kingston

Offer more diverse dining, including international cuisines, upscale eateries, and trendy cafes.

Rural Areas

Classic diners, delis, and traditional American fare remain prevalent, offering comforting, no-frills meals.

Dining Customs & Meal Times

  • Tipping: 15-20% for good service is customary.
  • Attire: Casual attire is generally acceptable; check websites for fine dining spots.
  • Reservations: Recommended for popular restaurants, especially on weekends or peak seasons.
  • Meal Times: Breakfast (7-10 AM), Lunch (11:30 AM-2 PM), Dinner (5-9/10 PM). Many smaller spots close mid-day.

Must-Try Dishes & Beverages

Signature Dishes & Snacks

Freshly Caught Trout

Found in eateries in Phoenicia or Livingston Manor, prepared pan-seared, smoked, or baked.

A testament to the region's strong fly-fishing heritage.

Maple Syrup Products

Enjoy maple creemees, maple-glazed dishes, candy, and pure syrup from local farm stands and markets.

Reflects New York's maple-producing tradition.

Apple Cider Donuts

A popular fall treat found at orchards and farm stands. Also look for homemade pies and local ice cream.

Seasonal delights from local bakeries and creameries.

Beverages & Dining Experiences

  • Craft Beverages: Sample local craft beers, hard ciders, and distilled spirits. Many offer tasting flights and tours.
  • Diner Classics: Experience classic American diner culture with hearty breakfasts, burgers, and comforting fare. Phoenicia Diner is a notable spot.
  • Farm-to-Table: Dishes incorporating seasonal produce, local meats, and artisanal cheeses reflect the strong connection to regional agriculture.
  • Farmers Markets: Seasonal markets offer prepared foods, baked goods, artisan breads, and savory treats from local vendors.

Seasonal & Festival Foods

Fall Harvest

Fall showcases apples, pumpkins, and various squashes. Apple and garlic festivals celebrate the harvest.

Spring Maple

Spring brings maple festivals (March), where sugar houses open for tours and tastings.

Dining Options

Fine Dining

Upscale culinary experiences highlighting local ingredients with refined menus.

  • The DeBruce (Livingston Manor)
  • Kenoza Hall (Kenoza Lake)
  • Deer Mountain Inn (Tannersville)

Mid-Range Options

Popular spots offering quality meals with a focus on local ingredients.

  • Phoenicia Diner (Phoenicia)
  • Prospect at Scribner's (Hunter)
  • Brushland Eating House (Bovina Center)

Budget & International

Affordable meals, casual fare, and diverse global flavors.

  • Local delis, pizza places, casual diners
  • Farmers Markets (seasonal)
  • International Cuisine (Kingston, Woodstock)

Special Dietary Considerations

Vegetarian & Vegan

Increasingly available, especially in Woodstock and Kingston. Check menus online or call ahead for smaller eateries.

Farm-to-table restaurants often have good options.

Gluten-Free & Allergens

Many establishments are aware and accommodating. Clearly communicate your needs to staff when ordering.

Online review sites offer filters for specific dietary needs.

Culinary Experiences

Farm Visits & U-Pick

Purchase fresh produce directly and explore local farms.

Brewery/Distillery Tours

Enjoy tastings and tours at local craft beverage producers.

Food Festivals

Seasonal events like Maple Weekends and Apple Festivals.

Roadside Diners

Experience classic American diner culture and history.

Culinary Immersion & Local Tips

Workshops & Classes

  • Cooking classes are occasionally offered by local farms or culinary schools.
  • Look for workshops on topics like cheesemaking or seasonal cooking.
  • Some art centers may host food-related creative workshops.
  • Check local event calendars for specific dates and availability.

Farm Visits & Producers

Farm Tours & Stands

Many farms offer tours, seasonal U-pick experiences, or farm stands for direct purchase of produce, cheeses, and meats.

Stone Ridge Orchard is a prominent example.

Local Agriculture Support

Purchasing directly from producers or at farmers markets supports local agriculture.

Catskill Animal Sanctuary also features a vegan cafe.

Food Festivals & Events

Events
Maple Festivals (Spring)
Garlic Festivals (Fall)
Apple Festivals (Fall)
Farmers Markets (Woodstock, Phoenicia)
Local Fairs (Ulster, Greene)
Taste of the Catskills Festival (Oct)
Unique Dining Concepts

Visit craft beverage producers like Catskill Brewery, Woodstock Brewing, Union Grove Distillery, and Abandoned Hard Cider. Many have taprooms with food.

  • Experience classic American diner culture.
  • Explore specialty food shops in Kingston Stockade District.
Local Farmers Markets

Abundant in warmer months, offering fresh produce, artisanal cheeses, and prepared foods.

Check local listings for operating hours and locations to enjoy these community hubs.

Additional Tips

Local Sourcing
  • Look for menus that highlight seasonal and local ingredients.
  • Support local farms and artisan producers directly.
Dining Experience
  • Enjoy diverse dining, from classic diners to upscale farm-to-table.
  • Embrace the region's evolving culinary identity.

Food & Drink Experiences

Local Producers & Tours

Brewery Tours

Visit Catskill Brewery in Livingston Manor, known for craft beers.

Woodstock Brewing | Phoenicia
Distillery Visits

Explore Union Grove Distillery in Arkville for local spirits.

Bourbon, Gin, Vodka
Hard Cidery Tastings

Visit Abandoned Hard Cider in Woodstock for unique apple ciders.

Refreshing Alternatives

Farm to Table & Local Markets

  • Explore local farms for tours or U-pick experiences (seasonal).
  • Purchase fresh produce, cheeses, and meats directly from farm stands.
  • Visit weekly farmers markets (Woodstock, Phoenicia, Kingston) for local goods.
  • Diners and casual eateries offer classic American comfort food.

Culinary Education & Events

Cooking Workshops

Occasionally offered by local farms or culinary schools on topics like cheesemaking or seasonal cooking.

Check local event calendars for specific offerings.

Seasonal Food Festivals

Participate in Maple Festivals in spring, or Garlic and Apple Festivals in the fall.

These events feature unique local specialties and regional products.

Spotlight on Local Favorites

Phoenicia Diner

An iconic spot serving elevated diner fare with fresh, local ingredients. Expect a wait during peak times.

The DeBruce

Acclaimed for its tasting menus highlighting local ingredients, offering an upscale dining experience in Livingston Manor.

Keegan Ales

A popular Kingston brewery that often features live music, serving local bands and touring acts.

Dining Tip

When dining in the Catskills, verify restaurant hours. Many smaller, independent eateries feature unique schedules and might close on specific weekdays or between lunch and dinner service.

  • A quick call or online check can save you a wasted trip.
  • Reservations are often beneficial for popular spots, especially on weekends.
  • Embrace the local, seasonal flavors.
  • Consider farm-to-table experiences for fresh ingredients.
  • Explore the growing craft beverage scene.