MileHacker Logo
Best Restaurants in Cape May

Best Restaurants in Cape May

Cape May New Jersey, USA Travel Guide

Culinary Overview

Cultural & Historical Context

Cape May's culinary scene is strongly shaped by its coastal location, emphasizing fresh seafood. As a historic resort town, it possesses a range of classic American and international cuisines.

The "Jersey Shore" food culture, with boardwalk specialties, also plays a part in the local flavors.

Dining Customs & Etiquette

  • Casual dress is fine at most places; dressy casual for fine dining.
  • Tipping (15-20% for good service) is customary.
  • Reservations are highly advised for popular restaurants, especially in peak season.
  • Many smaller eateries are "BYOB" (Bring Your Own Bottle), meaning you can bring your own wine or beer.

Ingredients & Flavors

Fresh Seafood

Crabs, scallops, flounder, and lobster are prominent. Many restaurants source seafood directly from local waters.

Jersey Produce Seasonal

In-season produce like sweet Jersey tomatoes, corn, and blueberries appear in many dishes.

Flavor Profile

Generally American, with influences from Italian, Mediterranean, and Asian cuisines.

Meal Times & Structure

  • Breakfast: Typically served from 7:00 AM to 10:00 AM. Many B&Bs include breakfast.
  • Lunch: Usually from 11:30 AM to 2:00 PM at casual eateries and cafes.
  • Dinner: Most restaurants are in operation around 5:00 PM and serve until 9:00 PM or 10:00 PM.
  • "Early Bird" specials, offering reduced prices before typical dinner hours, are common.

Must-Try Dishes

Signature Dishes

Fresh Seafood

Steamed Crabs (by the pound), Crab Cakes (lump crab meat), and Fresh-Caught Fish (flounder, striped bass).

America's Original seaside resort Scallops, often pan-seared, highlight natural sweetness.

Local Produce & Unique Finds

Jersey Tomato Salad: simple yet flavorful, with local tomatoes.

Crab Gravy: an unique South Jersey Italian-American dish with crabmeat in a rich red sauce, served over pasta.

Local Beverages

Local Craft Beer from America's Original seaside resort Brewing Company is widely available.

New Jersey Wines from local wineries like Willow Creek Winery and America's Original seaside resort Winery.

Street Food & Snacks

  • Saltwater Taffy: a classic Jersey Shore confectionery in countless varieties.
  • Fudge: many shops offer a wide selection of flavors.
  • Boardwalk Fries: thick-cut, often crinkle-cut, with toppings like cheese or vinegar.
  • Pizza: numerous pizzerias offer classic Jersey Shore slices, often thin-crust.

Iconic Desserts

Ice Cream

Many frozen dessert parlors offer various flavors, a quintessential Cape May treat.

Funnel Cake

A fried dough dessert, a popular boardwalk staple.

Dining Options

Fine Dining Establishments

Upscale American cuisine with a focus on local, ingredients in season. Reservations are highly advised.

  • The Ebbitt Room (The Virginia Hotel)
  • Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant (BYOB)
  • Union Park Dining Room (Congress Hall)

Mid-range Restaurants

Popular spots known for their fresh seafood, hearty breakfasts, and casual atmosphere.

  • The Lobster House (harbor)
  • George's Place (diner, for breakfast)
  • Black Duck on Sunset (American bistro)

Budget Eateries & Street Food

Affordable options for quick bites, including slices of pizza, sandwiches, and treats.

  • Freda's Cafe (casual breakfast/lunch)
  • Numerous deli/pizza shops
  • Washington Street Mall eateries, frozen yogurt, candy stores

Markets & Specialized Options

Cape May Fish Market

Located on the harbor, this market offers fresh seafood for those who wish to cook their own meals.

A great option for sourcing local catches directly.

Local Farmers Markets

Seasonal farmers markets provide fresh produce, baked goods, and local specialties.

Check local listings for operating days and locations.

Special Dietary Considerations

Vegetarian & Vegan

Increasingly available at many restaurants; ask your server for options.

Gluten-Free & Allergens

Many restaurants manage dietary restrictions; inform your server about allergies.

Halal & Kosher

Dedicated options are limited; consider adapting vegetarian/vegan dishes.

Dining Resources

Web-based feedback (Yelp, Tripadvisor) or calling ahead for specific needs.

Culinary Experiences

Immersive Food Experiences

  • Cooking Classes: Check with local culinary schools or Cape May MAC for demonstrations.
  • Farm Visits: Beach Plum Farm offers farm stands and fresh produce.
  • Winery Tastings: Explore local wineries like Willow Creek and Cape May Winery.
  • Food Tours: Look for food-focused walking tours providing insight into local ingredients.

Unique Dining Concepts

BYOB Restaurants

Many smaller restaurants operate as "Bring Your Own Bottle," allowing diners to bring their own alcohol.

Check if a restaurant is VIAOB before bringing alcohol.

Outdoor Dining

Many establishments feature charming outdoor seating, particularly along the Washington Street Mall and Beach Avenue.

A pleasant atmosphere, especially during warmer months.

Seasonal Food Festivals

Culinary Events
Cape May Restaurant Week
Craft Beer & Crab Fest
Local Farmers Markets
Winter Festival of Lights
Seasonal Pick-Your-Own Farms
Winery Events
Cape May Restaurant Week

Typically held in June and September, this event offers fixed-price menus at participating restaurants.

  • Excellent opportunity to sample various eateries.
  • Pre-set multi-course meals.
  • Reservations are highly recommended.
Craft Beer & Crab Fest

A seasonal event held in August, including local brews and fresh seafood.

Enjoy live music and an energetic ambiance by the beach.

Event Resources

Local Tourism Sites
  • General event listings
  • Restaurant directories
Restaurant Websites
  • Direct booking access
  • Menu updates

Planning & Tips

Dining Experiences to Consider

Harbor-side Seafood

Dine at bustling seafood restaurants situated right on the working harbor.

Fresh Seafood Lively Atmosphere
Find Seafood Restaurants
B&B Breakfasts

Enjoy gourmet breakfasts, often included with your stay at Victorian B&Bs.

Personalized Service
Explore B&Bs
Farm-to-Table Dining

Seek out restaurants that prioritize local, seasonal "Jersey Fresh" ingredients.

Support Local Farms
Local Restaurant Guide

Dining Considerations

  • Book ahead for fine dining and popular spots, especially during summer weekends.
  • Confirm if a restaurant is USINGOB; it can significantly reduce your beverage cost.
  • Inform staff about any food allergies or specific dietary needs.
  • Look at seasonal operating hours, as many places have reduced hours in the off-season.

Tips for a Smooth Experience

Research Menus Online

Browse menus beforehand to find dishes that appeal to you as well as verify pricing.

Many restaurants post current menus on their websites.

Use Restaurant Apps

Utilize apps like OpenTable for reservations or Yelp for feedback and local recommendations.

Handy for quick decisions while exploring.

Culinary Event Highlights

Restaurant Week

Fixed-price menus at top restaurants, typically during The month of june and September.

Craft Beer & Crab Fest

Enjoy local brews and fresh seafood, usually held in August.

Farmers Markets

Seasonal markets for fresh local produce and artisan goods.

Additional Dining Tips

For the freshest seafood, consider visiting dining places on the harbor or those advertising daily catches.

  • Always book for fine dining, especially on weekends.
  • Explore seasonal farmers markets for fresh, local ingredients.
  • Don't miss the local craft breweries for unique beverage experiences.
  • Check seasonal hours for all establishments, as they often vary.