MileHacker Logo
Best Restaurants in Cape Cod

Best Restaurants in Cape Cod

Massachusetts USA Travel Guide

Culinary Overview

Context and Ingredients

The Cape’s cuisine is shaped by its peninsula location in the Atlantic. Seafood is a way of life, reflecting centuries of fishing. Pilgrim settlers introduced simple, hearty preparations. Immigrant traditions later added to the culinary landscape.

The star is fresh lobster, clams (littlenecks, steamers, quahogs), oysters (Wellfleet), scallops (bay/sea), cod, haddock, and striped bass. Cranberries are a major local crop, in sauces, baked goods, and juices. Corn and blueberries are seasonal.

Dining Customs and Etiquette

  • Tipping 15-20% for waitstaff is customary and expected.
  • Reservations are highly recommended for popular restaurants, especially during high season or for groups. Fine dining often requires reservations.
  • Most dining establishments maintain a casual, relaxed atmosphere. Fine dining venues typically prefer smart casual attire.
  • Lunch is generally 12:00 PM - 2:00 PM. Dinner typically starts 5:00 PM - 9:00 PM/10:00 PM. Early bird specials are common.

Regional Variations

Outer Cape Wellfleet, Provincetown

Known for its oyster industry, notably briny Wellfleet oysters.

Mid-Cape/Lower Cape

More traditional New England seafood shacks, family-kid-friendly eateries, and classic American diners.

Upper Cape

A mix of traditional New England fare and more contemporary dining, influenced by mainland cities.

Meal Times and Structures

  • Breakfast: Often included at B&Bs. Diners and cafes offer American breakfast options.
  • Lunch: A casual affair, at seafood shacks, cafes, delis, or in the role of a beach picnic.
  • Dinner: The main meal, from relaxed family dining to upscale experiences.
  • Flavors: Simple preparations highlight fresh ingredients like butter, lemon, fresh herbs.

Must-Try Dishes

Signature Dishes

Lobster Roll

Chilled lobster meat (or warm with butter) tossed with mayonnaise, served in a grilled, buttered, top-split hot dog bun. Find it at most seafood shacks.

A classic The Cape experience.

New England Clam Chowder

A creamy, thick soup with tender clams, diced potatoes, onions, and often bacon. A staple on almost every menu.

Varies in richness and consistency.

Fried Clams and Fresh Oysters

Fried clams (whole-belly or strips) are lightly battered and deep-fried. Wellfleet oysters are famous for their briny, clean flavor, enjoyed raw.

Found at casual seafood shacks and oyster bars.

More Local Delights

  • Steamed "Steamers" (Soft-Shell Clams): Served with clam broth and melted butter for dipping.
  • Scallops: Pan-seared, fried, or baked. Smaller bay scallops are seasonal; larger sea scallops are year-round.
  • Battered fish And fries: Battered and deep-fried white fish (cod/haddock) with french fries.
  • Street Food Specialties: Seafood shacks with walk-up windows. Frozen yogurt stands are ubiquitous in summer.

Sweets and Drinks

Traditional Beverages

Cranberry-based drinks are popular. Local craft beers from breweries like Cape Cod Beer in Hyannis. Wineries also can be found.

Iconic Snacks and Desserts

Saltwater Taffy, Fudge, Cranberry Desserts (tarts, muffins, crisps), and Ice Cream from numerous local parlors.

Dining Options

Fine Dining

Located in upscale towns like Chatham, Provincetown, and Falmouth. They feature sophisticated menus, extensive wine lists, elegant ambiance, and professional service. Reservations are generally required.

  • Examples: Twenty-Eight Atlantic at Wequassett Resort (Harwich).
  • The Impudent Oyster (Chatham).
  • Fanizzi's Restaurant by the Sea (Provincetown).

Mid-Range Restaurants

The most common type of restaurant. They present a variety of cuisines (seafood, American, Italian, Mexican) in a comfortable setting. They provide a balance of food quality and fair prices.

  • Examples: Black Cat Tavern (Hyannis).
  • Land Ho! (Orleans).
  • The Lobster Pot (Provincetown).

Budget Eateries & Markets

Numerous casual seafood shacks, diners, and delis provide good value. Supermarket delis offer inexpensive what you need for a picnic. Farmers Markets are seasonal. Fish markets for fresh seafood.

  • Farmers Markets provide local produce and prepared foods.
  • Buy fresh seafood directly from local seafood markets.
  • International Cuisine: Available in larger communities like Hyannis and Provincetown.

Seasonal Foods & Events

Cranberry Harvest

October brings cranberry-themed dishes, products, and opportunities to visit bogs.

A major local crop.

Clam Bakes

Traditional New England outdoor feasts, often seasonal or by special event. They feature steamed clams, lobster, corn, and potatoes cooked over hot rocks.

A unique culinary tradition.

Dining Quick Facts

Simple Flavors

Emphasize fresh ingredients.

Early Bird Specials

Common at many restaurants.

Casual Dress

Typical for most places.

Parking

Consider in crowded places.

Special Dietary Considerations

Dietary Options

  • Vegetarian and Vegan options are increasingly available, especially in larger towns and diverse restaurants.
  • Health food stores carry specialty vegan and vegetarian goods for self-catering.
  • Many restaurants accommodate gluten-free, dairy-free, and other common allergies.
  • Supermarkets offer gluten-free and allergen-friendly alternatives.

Specific Needs & Communication

Halal and Kosher Availability

Limited dedicated Halal or Kosher restaurants. Visitors might depend on self-catering or pre-prepared meals. Kosher items are located in bigger supermarkets.

Plan ahead for strict requirements.

Communicating Allergies

Always inform your server plainly and directly about dietary needs when placing an order. Be aware of cross-contamination risks in smaller kitchens.

Clear communication is best.

Resources for Travelers

Online and App Resources
Check restaurant see menus on the internet in advance.
Use apps for identifying restaurants that are family-friendly.
HappyCow for vegetarian and vegan places.
Politely discuss needs with staff.
Larger supermarkets for specific products.
Some fine dining establishments may have pre-set menus.
Seasonal and Festival Foods

October brings cranberry-themed dishes. Wellfleet OysterFest during The month of october. Yarmouth Seaside Celebration in Fall.

  • Check local chamber of commerce websites for current event calendars.
  • Small local culinary events are held throughout the year.
  • Clam bakes are traditional The Northeastern us states outdoor feasts.
Unique Dining Concepts

Clam Shacks featuring Outdoor Seating offer fresh seafood in a casual, family-friendly setting.

Waterfront Dining has stunning views. Lobster Pounds allow picking live lobster for steaming.

Culinary Experiences and Resources

Engaging with Food Culture
  • Food Tours are available in Provincetown, Hyannis, and Chatham.
  • Cooking classes from private chefs or inns.
  • Wineries/Breweries like Cape Cod Beer offer tastings.
Farm and Producers Visits
  • Some oyster farms, especially in Wellfleet, offer tours.
  • Fresh markets provide local ingredients.
Important Dining Note
  • Seafood shacks prioritize fresh seafood over decor.
  • Many seafood shacks are in cash-only, so plan accordingly.

Culinary Experiences

Learning and Tours

Cooking Classes

Limited offerings, but some private chefs or inns may offer specialized cooking classes focusing on local ingredients or The Northeastern us states cuisine.

Focus: Local ingredients. Cuisine: The Northeastern us states seafood.
Explore Tours
Food Tours

Available in places such as Provincetown, Hyannis, and Chatham. These tours highlight regional seafood, historical eateries, or specific neighborhood culinary spots.

Insight into local food scene.
Find Culinary Walks
Farm Visits & Producers

Wineries in the vicinity and craft breweries offer tastings and tours. Some oyster farms, especially in Wellfleet, offer tours or tasting experiences.

A glimpse into local beverage/oyster production.
Discover Local Products

Festivals and Unique Concepts

  • Wellfleet OysterFest: Annual carnival in October celebrating local oysters with food vendors, music, and art.
  • Yarmouth Seaside Festival: A fall festival featuring food vendors, crafts, and entertainment.
  • Various smaller local culinary events happen throughout the year, especially in summer. Check local chamber of commerce websites.
  • A The Promontory cookbook brings local flavors home.

Unique Dining Concepts

Clam Shacks with Outdoor Seating

A quintessential The Cape experience. These casual eateries, often with picnic tables, serve fresh seafood in a relaxed, family-friendly atmosphere.

Concentrate on freshness, not decor.

Waterfront Dining & Lobster Pounds

Numerous restaurants offer stunning views of the ocean, bay, or harbors. Lobster Pounds allow picking a live lobster from a tank to be steamed and served, for a fresh experience.

Enhances the dining with scenic backdrops.

Dining Tips

Cash-Only Shacks

Many regional seafood shacks require cash-only operations. Come prepared to pay with cash to avoid inconvenience.

Seasonal Openings

Some eateries, especially casual shacks, work on a season-based basis. Verify their opening hours, especially during shoulder or off-peak seasons.

Fresh Seafood Focus

At seafood shacks, the emphasis is on the being fresh and quality of the seafood rather than luxurious decor or extensive menus.

General Dining Advice

Always communicate dietary restrictions clearly. Don't be afraid to ask about ingredients or methods of preparation.

  • Check online menus before visiting.
  • Call ahead for bookings, especially for larger groups.
  • Look for local "specials boards" for the newest catches.
  • Consider local craft breweries for unique beverage experiences.
  • Enjoy the relaxed, seaside ambiance of Cape Cod dining.