MileHacker Logo
Best Restaurants in Florida Keys

Best Restaurants in Florida Keys

Florida Keys Florida, USA Travel Guide

Culinary Overview

Ingredients and Flavors

Cuisine centers on the abundance of fresh seafood from the surrounding waters, tropical fruits that thrive in the climate, and a relaxed, "island time" approach to meals.

The "Conch Republic" identity of West has a distinct, quirky, and independent culinary scene.

Ingredients

  • Seafood: Freshly caught varieties dominate menus. Look for grouper, snapper, mahi-mahi, and swordfish. Stone crab claws (Oct 15 - May 15) and Florida lobster (Aug 6 - Mar 31) are highly prized.
  • Citrus: Limes are paramount, forming the base for Lime Pie and appearing in marinades, cocktails, and dressings.
  • Tropical Fruits: Mangoes, papayas, avocados, and plantains are common in salsas, desserts, and side dishes.
  • Spices and Flavors: Garlic, cilantro, cumin, and mild chilies are common flavor enhancers. Preparations often involve grilling, blackening, or frying.

Dining Customs & Etiquette

Atmosphere

Dining customs in the Keys are generally relaxed. Casual attire is acceptable in most establishments.

Reservations & Tipping

For upscale restaurants, making reservations, especially during high season, is recommended. Tipping is customary and expected (15-20% for good service).

Meal Times & Portions

Portions are typically generous. Meal times are similar to the rest of the U.S. (Breakfast: 7-11 AM, Lunch: 11:30 AM-2:30 PM, Dinner: 5-10 PM).

Regional Variations

  • Lime Pie and fresh seafood are ubiquitous throughout the Keys.
  • The Upper and Middle Keys often have more traditional fish houses, waterfront dining, and casual eateries catering to boating and fishing enthusiasts.
  • Happy hours with drink and appetizer specials are common in the late afternoon across the Keys.
  • Conch harvesting is regulated to protect populations.

Must-Try Dishes

Signature Dishes

Lime Pie

The quintessential dessert of the Florida Keys. This pie has the juice of tiny Limes, egg yolks, and sweetened condensed milk, all set in a graham cracker crust. It can be served baked, chilled, or even frozen on a stick.

Find at: Virtually every restaurant and dessert shop. Kermit's West Lime Shoppe is noteworthy.

Conch Fritters

Fried dough balls mixed with finely chopped conch (a large sea snail), vegetables, and spices. Golden brown and crispy, usually served with a dipping sauce.

Find at: Many seafood restaurants and casual eateries throughout the Keys.

Fresh Fish Sandwich

A simple yet delicious staple. Fish varies daily based on the catch. Fish can be grilled, blackened, or fried, then served on a bun with lettuce, tomato, and often a side.

Find at: Almost any casual waterfront restaurant or fish shack across the Keys.

Seasonal Delicacies

  • Stone Crab Claws (Seasonal: October 15 - May 15): A delicacy. Only the claws are harvested; the crab returns to the water. Cooked and chilled, served with a special mustard sauce.
  • Florida Lobster (Seasonal: August 6 - March 31): The spiny lobster, distinct from Maine lobster. Often grilled, broiled, or steamed, prized for its sweet tail meat.
  • Street food is less prevalent compared to some international destinations. Food trucks may offer conch fritters or fish tacos.
  • Iconic snacks and desserts beyond Lime Pie include various tropical fruit smoothies and coconut-based treats.

Traditional Beverages

Non-alcoholic

Freshly squeezed juices (orange, grapefruit) and iced tea are popular choices.

Alcoholic

Craft beers from local breweries (e.g., Florida Keys Brewing Co.), rum-based cocktails (Mojitos, Rum Runners), and local tropical cocktails with fresh fruit juices are common.

Dining Options

Fine Dining

Upscale atmospheres and refined menus.

  • West: Latitudes (Sunset ), Café Marquesa, Blue Heaven.
  • Islamorada: Pierre's Restaurant, Ziggie & Mac's.
  • International cuisine options are predominantly found in West.

Mid-Range Restaurants

Popular choices with fresh seafood and local views.

  • West: Santiago's Bodega (tapas), Half Shell Raw Bar, Salute! On the Beach.
  • Marathon: Lazy Days Restaurant, Keys Fisheries.
  • Largo: Mrs. Mac's Kitchen.

Budget & Local Eateries

Affordable options for quick and casual bites.

  • West: Local delis, sandwich shops, food trucks (e.g., Garbo's Grill), casual pizza places.
  • Throughout Keys: Many small, unassuming fish shacks.
  • Markets and food halls are limited. Grocery stores like Publix and Winn-Dixie are prevalent for self-catering.

Special Dietary Considerations

Vegetarian and Vegan Options

These are increasingly available, notably in West and at larger resorts. Many restaurants have fresh salads, pasta dishes, or specific vegetarian entrees.

Look for establishments that highlight fresh, local produce.

Gluten-Free and Allergen-Aware Dining

Many restaurants adapt to gluten-free, dairy-free, and other common allergies. It is always best to inform your server about any dietary restrictions when placing your order.

Halal and kosher availability is very limited throughout the Keys.

Resources for Specific Needs

Inform Server

Communicate allergies or dietary needs.

Use Apps

Apps like Yelp or HappyCow for filtered searches.

Check Menus Online

Research restaurant menus in advance.

Self-Cater

For specific dietary needs, self-catering may be best.

Culinary Experiences

Immersive Opportunities

  • Cooking Classes: Some guesthouses or private chefs in West may hold classes focusing on Keys cuisine or making Lime Pie.
  • Food Tours: Walking food tours are popular in West, having guided tastings and insights into the island's culinary history.
  • "Cook Your Catch": Many fishing charters partner with local restaurants that prepare your freshly caught fish for dinner.
  • Waterfront Dining: Numerous restaurants throughout the Keys have stunning views of the ocean or Gulf, especially at sunset.

Seasonal & Festival Foods

Florida Keys Seafood Festival

Held in West in January, it showcases the region's abundant fresh seafood.

Check seasonal availability of stone crab and Florida lobster before your trip.

Lime Festival

A lively event celebrating the famous pie with contests and tastings, held in West in July.

Fresh mangoes and other tropical fruits are abundant in the summer.

Culinary Highlights

Featured Dishes
Lime Pie Slice
Conch Fritters Plate
Waterfront Dining
Chef Preparing Fish
Lime Pie Slice

A classic Lime Pie slice on a plate.

Conch Fritters

A plate of fresh conch fritters with dipping sauce.

Dining Scenes

Dietary Information
  • Always inform your server about any dietary restrictions.
  • Most kitchens adapt dishes where possible.
Food Festivals
  • Florida Keys Seafood Festival (January, West).
  • Lime Festival (July, West).

Iconic Landmarks

West Landmarks

Southernmost Point Buoy

This brightly painted buoy marks the southernmost point of the continental United States, 90 miles from Cuba. It is one of the most photographed landmarks.

Accessible 24/7, no admission fee. | Expect lines for photos.
View Image
Ernest Hemingway Home & Museum

The former residence of the famous author, where he wrote many major works. Famous for its numerous six-toed cats.

Open daily 9 AM - 5 PM. Admission fee.
View Cat Image
Duval Street West

The commercial heart of West. It stretches from the Gulf of Mexico to the Atlantic Ocean.

Open 24/7. Individual shops/restaurants vary hours.
View Nightlife

Bridge & Views

  • Seven Mile Bridge (Marathon): An engineering marvel and a defining feature of the Overseas Highway. It connects Marathon to the Lower Keys.
  • Offers stunning panoramic views of the ocean. Part of the old bridge runs parallel, now a pedestrian and cycling path.
  • Insider Tip: Pull off at designated parking areas at either end of the old bridge for photos and to access the walking path.
  • Visitor Information: Always accessible by car. The old bridge segment is open for walking and cycling.

Other Tips

Best Photo Times

For Southernmost Point, arrive early morning (before 9 AM) or late afternoon (after 5 PM) to avoid queues.

Light for photography is softer during these times.

Hemingway Tour Info

Guided tours at Hemingway Home are informative and valuable. Allow 1 to 1.5 hours for your visit.

The tours have anecdotes about Hemingway's life.

Natural Attractions

John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park

First undersea park in the U.S. Great for snorkeling, diving, glass-bottom boat tours, and kayaking. Book tours in advance.

Bahia Honda State Park

Ranked among the best beaches. Clear waters for swimming, snorkeling, kayaking, and camping. Arrive early for parking.

Everglades National Park

Easily accessible from Largo (approx. 1-hour drive). Offers airboat tours, kayaking, and wildlife viewing for alligators and birds.

More Natural Wonders

Dagny Johnson Largo Hammock Botanical State Park: One of the largest remaining tracts of West Indian tropical hardwood hammock. Suitable for hiking and bird watching.

  • Scenic viewpoints like Seven Mile Bridge for panoramic ocean views.
  • Sunset at Mallory Square ( West): Daily tradition with street performers and vendors.
  • Wildlife viewing areas: National Deer Refuge (Big Pine ) for the Deer.
  • Birding is excellent, especially during migration seasons.
  • Beaches: West (Smathers Beach, Higgs Beach, Fort Zachary Taylor Beach), Marathon (Sombrero Beach).