MileHacker Logo
Best Restaurants in Mystic

Best Restaurants in Mystic

Mystic Connecticut, USA Travel Guide

Culinary Overview

Local Cuisine & Flavors

Mystic's culinary scene is deeply rooted in New England's maritime history and coastal geography. Seafood is central to the local diet. Early American and European settler influences are evident in hearty, wholesome comfort food traditions.

Expect fresh seafood, including lobster, scallops, cod, oysters, and clams. Other ingredients include corn, potatoes, maple syrup, cranberries, and apples. Flavors are often simple and fresh, focusing on ingredient quality. Butter is common with seafood, enhancing natural richness.

Dining Customs & Meal Times

  • Casual dining is common. Reservations are recommended for popular restaurants, especially on weekends and during peak season.
  • Tipping is customary. Wait to be seated in most sit-down restaurants.
  • Breakfast: 7:00 AM - 10:00 AM. Lunch: 12:00 PM - 2:00 PM. Dinner: 5:00 PM - 9:00 PM (later on weekends).
  • Many casual eateries and cafes offer continuous service throughout the day.

Regional Variations

Coastal Connecticut

Mystic's cuisine is influenced by fresh catches from the coastline, with seafood as a staple.

Inland Connecticut

Features more dairy products, apple orchards, and farm-to-table practices, showing a broader culinary landscape across the state.

General New England Staples

Hearty meals, comfort foods, and seasonal ingredients are common themes across the region.

Iconic Snacks & Desserts

  • Ice Cream: Mystic Drawbridge Ice Cream is a popular local spot for homemade ice cream with views of the drawbridge.
  • Donuts: Local bakeries often feature fresh, comforting donuts.
  • Seasonal Treats: Look for apple cider donuts in the fall.
  • Baked Goods: Various cafes offer cookies, muffins, and pastries for a sweet treat.

Must-Try Dishes

Signature Dishes

Lobster Roll

A New England staple, Mystic offers two styles: Hot Buttered (warm lobster meat tossed in melted butter, served in a grilled bun, found at Ford's Lobster) and Cold with Mayo (chilled lobster meat mixed with mayonnaise, served in a grilled bun, widely available).

A classic taste of the coast.

New England Clam Chowder

A creamy, thick soup featuring tender clams, potatoes, onions, and often bacon. Most seafood restaurants proudly serve this comforting dish.

Hearty and warming.

Fried Whole Belly Clams

A regional delicacy where entire clams, including the belly, are lightly battered and deep-fried. Discover this unique dish at seafood shacks and local restaurants.

A truly authentic seafood experience.

Local Favorites & Beverages

  • Mystic Pizza: Famous from the 1988 movie, this local institution at 56 W Main Street serves traditional pizza. A Mystic Pizza DVD can be a fun souvenir.
  • Street Food Specialties: Mystic has limited traditional "street food." Food trucks and casual seafood shacks may offer hot dogs, hamburgers, and fish & chips in warmer months.
  • Alcoholic Beverages: Explore craft beer from local breweries, like Cottrell Brewing Company. Local wines from nearby vineyards are also available.
  • Non-alcoholic Beverages: Enjoy fresh apple cider (especially in fall) and coffee from local roasters.

Seasonal & Festival Foods

Fall Flavors

Indulge in apple cider donuts, pumpkin-flavored items, and traditional clam bakes during the autumn season.

Summer Delights

Enjoy fresh corn on the cob and lobster bakes, celebrating the bounty of the summer season.

Dining Options

Fine Dining

Elevated culinary experiences focusing on local seafood and refined dishes.

  • Oyster Club: Farm-to-table concept, local seafood.
  • Bravo Bravo: Upscale Italian cuisine, refined atmosphere.
  • Reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends.

Mid-Range Restaurants

A balance of comfort, quality, and varied cuisine in a relaxed setting.

  • Sift Bake Shop: Award-winning bakery & café for pastries, sandwiches.
  • Red 36: Waterfront American cuisine and seafood, lively atmosphere.
  • Engine Room: Craft burgers, beer, cocktails in a rustic setting.

Budget & Casual Eats

Affordable and quick options, ideal for a casual meal or snack.

  • Mystic Pizza: Affordable pizzas and casual fare.
  • Dog Watch Cafe: Casual waterfront pub food and seafood.
  • Local Delis/Cafes: Sandwiches, soups, and salads.

Special Dietary Considerations

Vegetarian and Vegan Options

Increasingly available in most restaurants, often marked on menus. Fine dining and mid-range establishments are generally accommodating to special requests.

Many menus indicate options or are willing to adapt dishes.

Gluten-Free & Allergens

Many restaurants are aware of gluten-free needs and common allergens. Inform staff about dietary restrictions when ordering to ensure safe meal preparation.

Always communicate your needs clearly to restaurant staff.

International Cuisine & Markets

Italian

Pasta dishes, classic entrées.

Mexican

Tacos, burritos, and more.

Asian

Sushi, Chinese, Thai options.

Farmers' Markets

Seasonal fresh produce.

Culinary Experiences

Interactive Food Activities

  • Cooking Classes: Limited formal cooking classes. Some local B&Bs or small businesses may offer informal culinary experiences.
  • Food Tours: Walking food tours may be available seasonally; check with local tour operators for current offerings.
  • Farm Visits: Nearby farms offer seasonal visits, notably for ice cream or pumpkin patches.
  • Brewery/Vineyard Tours: Local vineyards and breweries offer tours and tastings, allowing you to sample regional products.

Unique Dining Concepts

Waterfront Dining

Dining at restaurants like Red 36 or Dog Watch Cafe offers scenic views of the Mystic River, creating a memorable meal.

Enjoy the views with your meal.

Historic Settings

Some establishments are located in historic buildings, adding character to your dining experience.

Dine in a piece of Mystic's past.

Seasonal Food Events

Food Festivals & Local Fairs
Farmers' Markets: Seasonal fresh produce.
Seafood Festivals: Check local calendars for dates.
Apple & Harvest Fairs: Common in fall.
Artisan Food Fairs: Local craft foods.
Ice Cream Socials: Summer traditions.
Brewery/Vineyard Events: Special releases and tastings.
Halal and Kosher Availability

Dedicated Halal or Kosher restaurants are limited. Supermarkets may carry some Kosher products.

  • Inquire directly with restaurants.
  • Consider preparing meals in vacation rentals.
  • Local grocery stores are the best source for specific ingredients.
Resources for Specific Dietary Needs

Use apps like Yelp or TripAdvisor and filter by dietary options. Call restaurants directly in advance to discuss your needs. Supermarkets offer specialized dietary products.

Local Food & Beverage Resources

Nearby Wineries
  • Stonington Vineyards
  • Maugle Sierra Vineyards
Local Breweries
  • Cottrell Brewing Company
  • Beer'd Brewing Co.

Culinary Experiences

Immersive Dining Activities

Local Bakery & Sweets

Visit Sift Bake Shop for award-winning pastries or Mystic Drawbridge Ice Cream for homemade flavors.

Sweet Treats | Local Flavors
Visit Sift Bake Shop
Craft Beer & Wine Tastings

Explore nearby breweries like Cottrell Brewing Company or Stonington Vineyards for local libations.

Regional Beverages
Discover Breweries
Seasonal Farm Experiences

Visit local farms like Buttonwood Farm for ice cream or a pumpkin patch, depending on the season.

Fresh & Local
Explore Farms

Beyond Traditional Dining

  • Informal Classes: Some B&Bs or small businesses may offer informal culinary experiences.
  • Local Food Tours: Check local tour operators for seasonal walking food tours in the area.
  • Seasonal Events: Consult the Mystic Chamber of Commerce events calendar for current listings of food festivals and fairs.
  • Artisan Producers: Discover local cheese makers, bakers, and specialty food shops.

Engaging with Local Food Culture

Support Local

Dine at establishments that source locally, supporting the region's farms and fisheries.

Taste the freshness of local ingredients.

Photo Opportunities

Capture the charm of waterfront dining, fresh seafood platters, or the atmosphere of a local farmers' market.

Create lasting memories of your culinary journey.

Local Culinary Hotspots

Downtown Eateries

A wide array of choices from casual cafes to upscale restaurants, many with river views.

Olde Mistick Village

Offers several dining spots within its charming, village-like setting.

Beyond the Center

Explore Route 27 and surrounding areas for additional restaurant choices, including larger chains.

Dining Tip

Local seafood is a highlight. Look for daily specials featuring fresh catches.

  • Ask about the "catch of the day."
  • Consider trying local oysters or clams.
  • Many restaurants source seafood directly from local waters.
  • Early dining may avoid peak crowds at popular spots.
  • Always inquire about ingredients if you have allergies.