MileHacker Logo
Best Restaurants in St Croix

Best Restaurants in St Croix

St Croix US Virgin Islands Travel Guide

Crucian Culinary Identity

Cultural Roots

The island's culinary traditions directly derive from its history. African culinary practices, brought by enslaved peoples, combined with European ways of cooking and local ingredients to form a distinct Crucian cuisine.

The Danish period, while focused on sugar production, influenced certain diet aspects. Today, the dishes tells a story of survival, adaptation, and celebration.

Ingredients & Flavors

  • Fresh seafood—mahi-mahi, snapper, wahoo, and conch are common catches.
  • Root vegetables like plantains, breadfruit, cassava, and yams form the backbone of many dishes, often referred to as "provisions."
  • Meat dishes frequently feature goat, chicken, and sometimes beef, seasoned generously.
  • Spices like thyme, garlic, onions, and scotch bonnet peppers provide bold, aromatic flavors, delivering a unique Caribbean warmth.

Regional Dining refinements

Traditional Eateries

More traditional Crucian fare, often hearty and flavorful, typically finds a home in local 'cook shops' or smaller, family-owned eateries outside the main tourist zones.

Christiansted Variety

Christiansted, with its larger number of restaurants, features a broader range of international cuisine and more refined dining experiences that incorporate local ingredients with modern twists.

Resort Offerings

Resorts often present a blend of international and Caribbean dishes.

Dining Customs & Etiquette

  • Dining is generally relaxed and casual. Dress codes are usually informal, even at mid-range restaurants, though fine dining establishments may suggest smart casual attire.
  • Tipping (15-20%) is customary and expected for good service, similar to the mainland U.S.
  • 'A slower rhythm' can apply to service, so patience is helpful; enjoy the relaxed pace.
  • Reservations are recommended for fine dining, especially during high season.

Must-Try Dishes

Signature Dishes

Callaloo

A thick, savory soup or stew made from callaloo greens (similar to spinach), okra, and often includes seafood (like crab or conch) or salted meat. A hearty and flavorful dish, usually accompanied by fungi or rice.

Find it at local eateries and some traditional restaurants.

Fungi Foon-jee

A tasty side dish resembling polenta or grits, made from cornmeal and okra. It has a smooth, thick consistency and often accompanies saltfish or stews.

A staple side dish.

Saltfish

Dried, salted codfish, rehydrated and cooked with various vegetables (onions, peppers) and spices. A flavorful and versatile dish, commonly served for breakfast or as a side with fungi or other provisions.

A versatile staple.

Traditional Beverages & Snacks

  • Sorrel: A sweet, spiced, deep red drink made from hibiscus flowers. Popular around Christmas time but found year-round.
  • Bush Tea: Various herbal teas made from local plants. Often consumed for traditional medicinal properties or in the capacity of a refreshing beverage.
  • Cruzan Rum: St. Croix houses the Cruzan Rum Distillery. Sampling their various rum expressions is a highly suggested activity.
  • Guanabana (Soursop) Juice: A creamy, sweet, and tangy juice made from the soursop fruit. It is refreshing and distinctive.

Iconic Snacks & Desserts

Johnny Cakes

Small, fried dumplings, slightly sweet, with a soft interior and crispy exterior. A versatile staple, often served as a side with savory dishes or like a breakfast item.

Tamarind Stew/Balls

Sweet and tangy confections made from the pulp of the tamarind fruit, often rolled into balls. They offer an unique tropical flavor.

Dining Options

St. Croix caters to diverse dining preferences, from elegant fine dining to casual local eateries. Options for every budget and taste are available.

Fine Dining

For a special evening, St. Croix features several upscale dining experiences. The Galleon at The Buccaneer resort, has sophisticated cuisine with ocean views. Balter in Christiansted offers a contemporary Caribbean menu with a focus on fresh, local ingredients. Savant, also in Christiansted, enjoys recognition for its creative menu and personal ambiance. Reservations are highly suggested for these venues, especially during high season.

  • Upscale vibe and service.
  • Extensive wine and cocktail lists.
  • Reservations recommended.

Mid-Range Restaurants

A broad range of mid-range restaurants present quality meals at more accessible prices. Rowdy Joe's is a popular spot for its casual atmosphere and diverse menu. Shupe's on the Boardwalk and Rum Runners, both on the Christiansted Boardwalk, feature casual American and Caribbean fare with waterfront views. Blue Water Terrace on the The Eastern part serves delicious cuisine in a relaxed setting. These establishments work well for a comfortable, enjoyable meal without excessive cost.

  • Good value for quality meals.
  • Relaxed and welcoming atmosphere.
  • Many waterfront locations available.

Budget & Street Food

For authentic local flavors and budget-friendly meals, seek out the island's local 'cook shops' or food vans. These often present daily specials of traditional Crucian dishes at very affordable prices. The Christiansted Boardwalk also has various casual options, including cafes and snack bars. The La Reine Farmers Market on Saturdays serves as an excellent place to experience local produce and prepared foods. Do not hesitate to ask locals for their favorite hidden gems.

  • Very cheap and genuine.
  • Hearty local dishes available.
  • Great for quick, casual meals.

International Cuisine

Variety in Christiansted

Beyond Caribbean fare, St. Croix features a range of international cuisine, specifically in Christiansted. You will find restaurants serving Italian, Asian (Chinese, Thai), and American comfort food.

This variety caters to all palates.

Global Flavors

From sushi to pasta, many restaurants incorporate fresh local ingredients into global dishes, creating unique fusion flavors.

Explore different dining experiences more than just traditional Crucian food.

Market & Food Spots

La Reine Farmers Market

Best for local produce, baked goods, and crafts. Saturdays only.

Christiansted Market Square

Limited daily vendors for fresh fruits and vegetables.

Supermarkets

Plaza Extra & Cost-U-Less for wider selection, specialty foods.

Local Produce

Roadside stands for island-grown specialties. Support local farms.

Special Dietary Considerations

Dietary Options

  • Vegetarian and vegan options are becoming more common on St. Croix, especially in Christiansted restaurants. Many local dishes feature plant-based ingredients like plantains, rice, beans, and fresh vegetables.
  • When ordering, clearly state your dietary needs. You might ask for modifications to traditional dishes, like ensuring no meat or fish broth. Look for restaurants explicitly mentioning vegetarian-friendly menus.
  • Gluten-free and other allergen-aware dining: Inform restaurant staff about any allergies (e.g., gluten, nuts, dairy). Cross-contamination can be a concern in smaller kitchens. Many local dishes, based on naturally gluten-free ingredients, can be safe. Always double-check with your server about ingredients and ways of preparing food.
  • Carry a Translation card if you have a severe allergy and language could be a barrier, although English is widely spoken.

Specific Considerations

Halal & Kosher

Halal and kosher options are extremely limited on St. Croix. No dedicated halal or kosher restaurants or certified butchers exist.

Travelers with strict requirements should plan to self-cater or carefully choose known acceptable dishes. Larger supermarkets may carry some pre-packaged international foods that fit these needs.

Customization & Communication

For successful dining with dietary needs, clear communication with restaurant staff holds value. Inquire about ingredients and cooking methods.

Some restaurants accommodate special requests given advance notice. Calling ahead is a good approach.

Culinary Experiences

Beyond Dining
Cooking Classes & Food Tours
Farm Visits & Food Producers
Food Festivals & Events
Unique Dining Concepts
Local Culinary Demonstrations
Try Local Produce
Local Dining Guides

Explore local guides and websites for restaurant listings and menus.

  • Christiansted Restaurant Guide
  • Frederiksted Places To eat
  • The Eastern district Eateries
Online Resources

Use reviews on the internet and travel forums to find specific dietary accommodations.

Contact restaurants in advance to validate their capacity for special dietary requests.

Digital Resources & Links

Local Markets
  • La Reine Farmers Market Information
  • Local Produce Seasonal Availability
Crucian Cuisine Deep Dive
  • History of Crucian Food
  • Traditional Recipes & Ingredients

Culinary Experiences

Beyond simply dining, St. Croix features unique culinary experiences that deepen your appreciation for the island's food culture. These activities make it possible to immerse yourself in local flavors and traditions.

Cooking Classes & Tours

Local Culinary Workshops

Some native chefs, guesthouses, or cultural centers may offer informal cooking demonstrations or classes focused on Crucian cuisine.

  • Learn traditional Crucian recipes.
  • Discover local ingredients.
  • Engage with island culinary traditions.
  • Hands-on experience with local flavors.
Farm Visits & Producers

offers tours, programs for education, and sometimes farm-to-table dinner events. See how local produce grows and learn about sustainable agriculture on the island. Check their schedule for public access or events.

  • Experience farm-to-table dining.
  • Understand organic farming practices.
  • Connect with local food systems.
  • Support local agriculture directly.

Festivals & Unique Dining

Food Festivals & Events

Taste of St. Croix (March/April) is the island's premier food and wine festival, showing local chefs and purveyors. Mango Melee (July) celebrates the mango harvest with mango-themed dishes and drinks. AgriFest (February) is an agricultural fair highlighting local produce, livestock, and traditional foods.

  • These occasions have real tastes of island life and gastronomic traditions.
  • Experience the local food scene.
  • Seasonal events for unique flavors.
  • Connect with the community through food.
Unique Dining Concepts

Many dining spots beside the Christiansted Boardwalk offer open-air dining with ocean breezes. Consider a sunset dinner cruise. 'Pop-up' dining experiences might appear; check social media or local event listings.

  • Enjoy meals with scenic backdrops.
  • Experience exclusive chef's dinners.
  • Discover innovative culinary twists.
  • Dine in unique, often temporary, settings.

Specialty Dining Experiences

  • Private Chef Services

    For a bespoke culinary experience, consider hiring a private chef to prepare meals at your vacation rental. Menus are tailored to your preferences, using fresh, local ingredients.

  • Restaurants With a sea view

    Many St. Croix restaurants are situated right on or near the beach, offering stunning views and a relaxed ambiance. Ideal for romantic dinners or family meals.

  • Food Truck & Pop-Up Scene

    Keep an eye out for local street food vendors and pop-up occasions that offer a diverse range of quick and tasty meals, from traditional fare to international fusion.

  • Fresh Catch Experiences

    Some local eateries specialize in the fresh catch of the day, permitting you to savor seafood straight from the ocean to your plate.

Culinary Learning & Insights

  • History of Crucian Cuisine

    Learn about the blend of African, European, and Caribbean influences defining the island's unique food identity.

  • Local Ingredient Spotlights

    Discover the importance of fresh seafood, root vegetables, and island spices in traditional Crucian dishes.

  • Dining Etiquette

    Familiarize yourself with local dining customs, including casual dress codes and tipping practices.

  • Culinary Literature

    Seek out local cookbooks or food blogs to explore Crucian cuisine in depth prior to or following your trip.

Beyond the Restaurant

Island Farm Experiences

Some farms offer tours where you can learn about local agriculture and taste freshly harvested produce. This connects you directly to the source of island food items.

  • Visit organic farms.
  • Learn about tropical fruit cultivation.
  • Participate in farm-to-table dinners.
  • Aid eco-friendly farming.
Home-Style Cooking Opportunities

Consider booking a vacation rental with kitchen facilities to experiment with local ingredients yourself, or seek out local cooking classes.

  • Shop at local markets for fresh produce.
  • Try cooking Crucian dishes.
  • Host a private dinner at your rental.
  • Learn from local home cooks.

Local Beverage Exploration

Rum Distillery Tours

Visit the Cruzan or Captain Morgan distilleries to learn about rum production and enjoy tastings. A quintessential St. Croix experience.

Local Juice Stands

Seek out roadside stands offering freshly squeezed tropical fruit juices like passion fruit, soursop, or mango. Refreshing and authentic.

Sunset Cocktail Spots

Enjoy a Crucian cocktail at a beachfront bar while watching the sunset. Many Christiansted and Frederiksted spots offer this.

Culinary Tips

Embrace the relaxed 'a relaxed pace' for service. It makes for a nicer dining experience.

  • Try local cook shops for authentic, budget-friendly meals.
  • Visit La Reine Farmers Market for farm-fresh produce and local treats on Saturdays.
  • Always ask about daily specials for the freshest catch.
  • Inquire about dietary restrictions well in advance, especially for small eateries.
  • Do not hesitate to sample the different local rum flavors.