MileHacker Logo
Culinary Journey in St Augustine

Culinary Journey in St Augustine

Florida, USA

Local Flavors and Dining Etiquette

Signature Ingredients

  • Fresh Seafood:

    Shrimp, oysters, and local fish are menus staples.

  • Datil Pepper:

    A local chili with distinct heat and fruity undertones.

  • Local Produce:

    Seasonal ingredients and citrus fruits are widely used.

  • Southern Staples:

    Expect grits, biscuits, and various fried dishes.

Dining Etiquette

  • Tipping:

    15-20% of the pre-tax bill for good service.

  • Dress Code:

    Casual attire common; smart-casual for fine dining.

  • Reservations:

    Recommended for popular restaurants, especially weekends.

  • Service:

    Attentive yet non-intrusive service.

Culinary Highlights

St. Augustine boasts several unique dishes that reflect its heritage. Explore these local favorites.

Minorcan Clam Chowder

Taste Profile
  • Rich, tomato-based with distinctive Datil pepper kick.
  • Unique to St. Augustine.
Where to Find
  • O'Steen's Restaurant
  • The Conch House Restaurant

Fresh Local Seafood

Taste Profile
  • Shrimp, oysters, and various local fish.
  • Often grilled, blackened, or fried.
Where to Find
  • Catch 27
  • Fish Camp
  • St. Augustine Fish House & Oyster Company

Datil Pepper Delights

Taste Profile
  • Various hot sauces, jellies, seasonings.
  • Featured in marinades, glazes, cocktails.
Where to Find
  • Local shops
  • Many restaurants

Additional Culinary Notes

Sweet Tea

A quintessential Southern beverage, found everywhere.

Lime Pie

A popular dessert throughout Florida.

Dining Options for Every Palate

St. Augustine presents a wide array of dining experiences, from elegant settings to casual eateries, with options for specific dietary needs.

Fine Dining

  • Michael's Tasting Room: Spanish-inspired tapas.
  • Preserved Restaurant: Modern Southern cuisine.
  • Casa Monica Resort & Spa (Costa Brava): Elegant Mediterranean dining.
  • Collage Restaurant: International cuisine, fresh seafood.

Mid-Range Favorites

  • The Floridian: Creative Southern comfort food.
  • Catch 27: Fresh, local seafood creations.
  • Gas Full Service Restaurant: Eclectic American fare.
  • Prohibition Kitchen: Gastropub with craft beers.

Dietary Considerations

Vegetarian & Vegan
  • Many restaurants have marked vegetarian options.
  • Vegan choices are growing.
Allergen Awareness
  • Restaurants accommodate gluten-free and other requests.
  • Communicate needs to staff clearly.

Special Notes

Halal & Kosher

Dedicated options limited. Rely on supermarkets or compliant dishes.

Budget Eats

Casual cafes, sandwich shops, and farmers markets.

International Cuisine

Italian, Mexican, Asian, Caribbean options are available.

Unique Culinary Experiences

Beyond traditional dining, St. Augustine presents unique experiences to deepen your appreciation for local flavors and traditions.

Food Tours & Workshops

St. Augustine Food Tours

Guided walking tours combine sightseeing with culinary stops.

  • Sample local specialties.
  • Learn about city history.
  • A structured food scene experience.
  • Explore options on GetYourGuide.
Local Cooking Classes

Periodic classes focus on regional cuisine or Southern techniques.

  • Look for Datil pepper dishes.
  • Check local event listings.

Signature Dining Concepts

The Ice Plant Bar & Restaurant

Farm-to-table dining in a restored 1927 ice plant.

  • Focus on fresh, local ingredients.
  • Craft cocktails featuring local spirits.
The Conch House Restaurant

Outdoor dining in thatched-roof grass huts over water.

  • Tropical ambiance.
  • Views of the Matanzas River.
  • Specializes in seafood.

Food Festivals

  • Datil Pepper Festival:

    Annual event in October celebrating the unique local pepper.

  • Seafood Festivals:

    Seasonal events celebrating fresh catches with live music.

  • Spanish Wine & Food Festival:

    Highlights Spanish heritage with culinary events and tastings.

  • Savor St. Augustine:

    Look for restaurants participating in special events and deals.

Local Beverage Producers

  • San Sebastian Winery:

    Tours and tastings of Florida wines, rooftop bar with views.

  • St. Augustine Distillery:

    Free tours and tastings of locally made spirits.

  • Craft Beverages:

    Growing scene with local breweries and unique cocktails.

  • Sweet Tea:

    A pervasive Southern iced black tea, available everywhere.

Plan Your Culinary Adventure

Online Resources

Use apps like Yelp or HappyCow for restaurant information and filters for specific dietary needs.

Direct Communication

The most reliable approach: clearly state dietary requirements with restaurant staff when making a reservation or upon arrival.

Explore More

Seasonal Delights

Look for special menus and deals if your visit aligns with "Savor St. Augustine" events or "Restaurant Week."

Local Markets

Consider visiting The Farmer's Market for fresh produce and prepared foods, ideal for budget-friendly meals or picnics.

Culinary Growth

The city's craft beverage scene continues to grow, with local breweries and distilleries offering unique tastes.