MileHacker Logo
Accommodation Guide

Accommodation Guide

Florida, USA

Accommodation Types

Common Options

  • Hostels

    Found mainly in West, hostels have budget-friendly dormitory beds and some private rooms. They are popular among solo travelers seeking a social atmosphere.

  • Motels

    Abundant throughout the Keys, especially in the Upper and Middle Keys. Motels often include simple, clean, and practical accommodations, sometimes with direct access to parking.

  • Guesthouses & B&Bs

    A popular choice in West, these are often historic homes converted into charming inns. They allow a more intimate experience, frequently including breakfast, and present a taste of West's unique architectural heritage.

  • Hotels

    Ranging from budget-friendly chain hotels to upscale boutique properties. Hotels are throughout the Keys, with a higher concentration in West, Marathon, and Islamorada.

Diverse Stays

  • Resorts

    Larger properties having extensive amenities like pools, private beaches, multiple restaurants, and water sports centers. Resorts are common in Largo, Islamorada, and Marathon, catering to travelers seeking a comprehensive, amenity-rich experience.

  • Vacation Rentals

    Homes, condos, and apartments are available for rent through platforms like Vrbo and Airbnb. These are specifically popular for families or longer stays, having more space, privacy, and often kitchen facilities.

  • Camping and outdoor accommodation

    A direct connection to the Keys' natural environment. Several state parks and private campgrounds have tent and RV sites.

  • Unique local accommodation types

    Many guesthouses in West maintain the historic "Conch House" architecture, with a glimpse into the island's past.

Neighborhood Guide

The Florida Keys comprise many distinct islands, each with its own character and appeal.

Largo Upper Keys

Pros
  • Proximity to John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park
  • Numerous dive shops
  • Convenient access from Miami or Fort Lauderdale
  • Accommodation is generally more affordable than in West
Cons
  • Can feel more commercial and less unique "Keysy"
  • Generally safe
  • Closest to Everglades National Park on the mainland
  • Generally quiet ambiance

Islamorada Upper Middle Keys

Pros
  • World-class fishing opportunities
  • Quality dining
  • Beautiful resorts
  • Less crowded atmosphere than West
Cons
  • Accommodation tends to be at a higher price point
  • Very safe
  • A good central base for exploring both the Upper and Middle Keys
  • Relaxed and sophisticated ambiance

Marathon Middle Keys

Pros
  • Central location for day trips
  • Good value for money on accommodations
  • Family attractions
  • Excellent access for fishing and boating
Cons
  • Can be busy with traffic
  • Possesses less historic charm compared to West
  • Generally safe
  • A lively, practical town ambiance

Neighborhood Details

Big Pine & Lower Keys

These Keys are more natural and less developed, home to the National Deer Refuge. They include a quieter, nature-focused experience. Benefits include Bahia Honda State Park and opportunities for wildlife viewing. Fewer dining and nightlife options. Very safe. Quiet, rural ambiance.

West (Lower Keys)

The southernmost point of the continental U.S. Known for its lively Duval Street, distinct historic architecture, and famous sunset celebrations. Benefits include abundant dining, nightlife, museums, historic sites, and a highly walkable layout. It is the most expensive for accommodations and overall costs. Can be very crowded. Generally safe, but be mindful of petty crime in crowded areas. Can be noisy and bustling.

Booking Strategies

Smart booking strategies secure your preferred accommodation.

Advance Booking Recommendations by Season

  • High Season (November to April): Book 4-6 months in advance, especially for specific guesthouses, popular resorts, or special events.
  • Shoulder Season (May and October): Book 2-3 months in advance.
  • Low Season (June to September): Book 1-2 months in advance. More last-minute deals might appear.
  • Seasonal price fluctuations are significant. Summer (low season) generally has the best value.

Trusted Booking Platforms

  • Online Travel Agencies (OTAs): Booking.com, Expedia, and Hotels.com have a wide selection.
  • Vacation Rentals: Vrbo and Airbnb are excellent platforms.
  • Direct Booking: Many independent guesthouses often prefer direct bookings via their own websites.
  • Hotel Chains: IHG Hotels for various brands.

Policies and Customs

Negotiation
  • Negotiation customs for walk-in rates are not customary in the Florida Keys.
  • Published rates are generally firm.
  • Attempting to negotiate prices, especially during busy seasons, will likely not be successful.
Deposit and Cancellation Policies
  • Deposit and cancellation policies vary widely by property and booking platform.
  • Always check these policies carefully before finalizing your reservation.
  • Many properties have stricter cancellation policies during peak season or for non-refundable rates.
  • Understand what happens if your plans change.

Additional Options

Budget Stays

Hostelworld for budget accommodations.

Unique Stays

TrustedHousesitters for house/pet sitting exchanges.

Asian Market Focus

Agoda for accommodation booking, strong in Asia.

Accommodation Recommendations

This comparison of accommodation types across various categories helps you choose based on your budget, travel style, and preferences.

Mid-Range Options

West Historic Guesthouses/B&Bs

Charming, unique character, often includes breakfast, central location.

  • Price Range: $250 - $450
  • Can be booked far in advance
  • Some lack modern amenities
Islamorada Boutique Hotels

Beachfront access, good amenities, relaxed atmosphere.

  • Price Range: $300 - $550
  • Less walkable for dining/shops
  • May require driving

Luxury Options

West Luxury Resorts

High-end service, prime location, exquisite design, private pools.

  • Price Range: $500 - $1000+
  • Very expensive
  • Often adults-only
Islamorada High-end Resorts

Full-service amenities, private beaches, spa, fine dining, activities.

  • Price Range: $600 - $1500+
  • Very exclusive
  • Often a destination in itself, less local interaction

Family-Friendly Stays

  • Marathon Vacation Rentals

    Space for families, kitchens, multiple bedrooms, often pools. Requires more self-sufficiency, may be further from attractions.

  • Largo Resorts with Kids' Programs

    Kid-friendly pools, activities, dining options, safe environment. Can be crowded, higher cost, less authentic experience.

  • Bahia Honda State Park Camping

    Beach camping sites, often booked far in advance. Consistently ranked as one of the best beaches in the U.S.

  • Curry Hammock State Park Camping

    Beachfront camping in a natural setting. Provides a direct connection to the Keys' natural environment.

Long-Stay & Unique Options

  • All Keys Vacation Rentals

    VRBO and Airbnb or Extended Stay Hotels. Kitchens, laundry, more space, feels like home. Less daily service, higher upfront cost.

  • West Historic Guesthouses

    Authentic West charm, unique decor, rich history. Can be older, may lack modern amenities (e.g., elevators).

  • West Hostels (Solo Traveler)

    Easy to meet other travelers, social events, central location. Less privacy, dormitory style.

  • John Pennekamp State Park Camping

    Limited camping. Often booked many months in advance due to its popularity.

Image Examples

Charming West Guesthouse

A historic West guesthouse with a porch and tropical plants, exemplifying authentic island charm.

Luxury Resort Pool & Ocean View

A luxury resort pool with palm trees, the ocean in the background, showing an amenity-rich experience.

More Accommodation Visuals

Bahia Honda State Park Camping

A camping tent set up on a beach at Bahia Honda State Park, illustrating an outdoor accommodation option.

Florida Keys Regions Map

A map highlighting different Keys regions (Upper, Middle, Lower Keys) for orientation.

Camping Tent Amazon

For camping enthusiasts, a Camping tent for outdoor stays.